Skip to main content

On Sale: GamesAssetsToolsTabletopComics
Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Song Creator Pro

Create brand new songs or remix existing ones — all on your PC. No subscriptions. · By Mortar Tribe

Questioning the QUALITY of musical generations

A topic by jerome74 created Mar 30, 2026 Views: 255 Replies: 2
Viewing posts 1 to 3

Generations are finally working with the new update, however the quality of the generations is identical to the free tool available on pinokio in one click : https://github.com/BazedFrog/SongGeneration-Studio

What's the point of paying for something that doesn't add value? Are there other options planned to improve the experience?

Developer (5 edits)

Hey! Good questions and apologies for the broken generations, I've been working on fixes all weekend. I'll start with the differences:

  • The repo you linked requires a minimum of 10GB of VRAM. Song Creator works on 8GB (possibly 4GB too) and without a GPU at all. 
  • The repo uses a model that does not allow commercial use of generated songs (this is a big one).

And some planned features:

  • A full REST API for programmatic generation
  • A Web UI for accessing SCP via a browser on other devices
  • The ability to fix/improve sections of generated songs Released in v.1.2.3
  • Extracting/Adding instruments Released in v.1.2.3
  • (Long-term) More/Better models as they're released
  • (Long-term) A native MacOS app

My goal with SCP is to make song creation as easy as possible from installation to generation. As you noticed, I only just got v1 stable and it has what I'd consider the bare minimum features for song generation so there's plenty of work left to do.

Having said all that, the roadmap isn't set in stone so if you have any feedback for new features or improvements, I'm all ears!

Thank you for your feedback. The ability to extract and add instruments is indeed interesting, and perhaps the option to retrieve the different tracks separately would be beneficial. Something to keep an eye on.