So itch.io has joined Steam, Patreon, Gumroad, and other sites like them in censoring the art that can be hosted and sold on its platform. itch has cited pressure from their payment processors (Visa, Mastercard, PayPal, Stripe, etc.) and anti-porn activist group Collective Shout, which has some interesting ties to other conservative, pro-censorship movements.
(I've linked to archived versions of those articles because the original publisher, Vice, later deleted them from its website due to their "controversial content.")
First off, banning adult content from a platform doesn't actually remove it from the platform. It just removes the incentive for creators to properly flag and categorize their work, as doing so becomes the most effective and immediate way to get it deleted. Instead, creators invariably start using euphemistic categories and tags—or, even worse, stop tagging their work at all. And that only increases the odds that you (or your kid) will end up seeing something you don't want to see.
Secondly, you may note itch's wording on what kind of content they will and won't allow going forward is deliberately vague, offloading responsibility to the site's payment processors. This is because it's actually against censors' best interests to provide clear rules on what they do or do not prohibit. It's not logistically feasible to identify and punish every possible infraction; instead, censors make the rules vague and confusing, the punishment clear and specific, and rely on fear and doubt to force self-censorship on their target population.
I've seen defenders of these policies claim that they're just targeting specific forms of porn which "glorify" taboos like rape, incest, and child abuse—but it's clear that creators examining these subjects from an artistic, literary perspective are also being censored, because the moderation systems in place on these platforms either don't know or don't care what "glorifying" actually means.
Call me an "apologist" all you want, but if you can't tell the difference between rape fetish porn and Toni Morrison's Beloved, you're not in a position to cast moral judgment on either of those things.
I don't appear to have been caught in the ban (yet), but I can't guarantee indefinite access to my work through this platform; censorship policies banning kink and pornography today can easily be weaponized against any kind of queer art tomorrow. If you've bought books from me on itch, I recommend downloading and archiving all of them.
itch.io also allows its sellers to choose how much of their revenue to share with the platform. Historically my revenue share with itch has been set to 10%, meaning itch received ⅒th of the cover price on every book I sold through their site. In recognition of itch's cowardice, I've reduced my revenue share to 0%. It will stay there until these censorship policies are reversed.
Did you like this post? Tell us
Leave a comment
Log in with your itch.io account to leave a comment.
Is this why my post have been pending for review under potential abuse for over a month now? Because parody games i posted or original ideas I had were all queer themed?
Totally nuts. If i'm paying to games through this site then that should be all the proof you need and there should be no blocked content.
Sadly i'm now starting to jump boat to look elsewhere for the same content that used to be accessible here.
fuck Collective Shou, Visa, Mastercard, and PayPal thru companies we fall. not that it changes anything but hers another website that might help https://ncac.org/