Play game
Companhita's itch.io pageResults
| Criteria | Rank | Score* | Raw Score |
| User Interface (UI/UX) | #15 | 2.750 | 2.750 |
| Fun | #18 | 2.500 | 2.500 |
| Overall | #18 | 2.750 | 2.750 |
| Visuals(Graphics) | #27 | 2.250 | 2.250 |
| Sound/Audio | #30 | 1.250 | 1.250 |
Ranked from 4 ratings. Score is adjusted from raw score by the median number of ratings per game in the jam.
DevLog Link
https://overbern.itch.io/companhita/devlog/1507472/alpha-5-img-jam-44
Developer Feedback Questions
Is there anything that happens that you don't understand at all?
Do any of the tutorials feel unnecessary?
How far did you get?
Leave a comment
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.
Comments
The first thing I noticed is that when the game starts it switches to fill the browser window, but the game itself does not scale with the window. Instead it locks to the top left of the window. I can resize and move the window, but it would be nice if it was centered, rather than at the top left. Not a huge issue, but a nice-to-have.
We appreciate being mentioned in the playtesting credits.
The font is much more readable now. While I do like the pixel aesthetic, I think the UI changes will help a lot with conveying information to players. There is so much to learn to be able to enjoy the game, that this should really help with getting people ready to start playing.
I like the popups giving tips spread out over the fight, with more advice the longer it takes. The tips also feel more clear than I remember them being in the past.
I think that I got notified of both winning and losing the first phase of the first fight. I was next to the enemy and both of us were low on health. They moved, taking enough damage to be at 0 HP. Then I took damage. I got a popup at the center saying I lost, but also see that everyone is healed to full HP, and the second character is being added, along with some dialog. I'll add a screenshot below.
I think that when you gain the second person it would be good to mention how polearms work, specifically how clicking on a diagonal turns them to aim their reaction area.
It took me a few tries to beat the first fight. When I did, it took 9 turns.
I would make the Mechanics Reference panel taller to allow more of the longer sections to be visible at the same time. I'd also suggest making the "close" button be in with the other buttons on the Pause menu, and possibly rename it to "Resume". When I first exited the Mechanics Reference it took me a bit to see it due to be so much smaller than the other buttons. I went through the big ones twice to see if I had missed it before noticing it. I think part of that was size, and part due to the color being close enough to the ground behind it. Personally, I'd also give the Pause menu's panel a content margin of 1-2 pixels all around. Right now it looks like there is a margin on the left, with the right and bottom having the shadow look a bit like a margin.
It would also be nice if you put all the mechanics in there. Things like Doubt do have popup help, but as I'm learning things I may think of something while a mechanic is not on screen and want to double check how it works.
It looks like "Get Ready" cannot be used on someone who has "Trip". I don't recall seeing that mentioned, so not sure if it is intentional or not. I can see it making sense to work this way.
I used an attack on my turn to finish off the last of the enemy's phase three health. They went back to full with no indication of why. At the start of my next turn I got the Endgame text and popup with info on it. It was my last move, so I can't say what else may happen from this, but I could see using it in a strategy to try taking them to the transition at the start of your turn and doing extra damage to their phase 4 state before the limits are in place.
I did not do well on the last phase. The enemy seemed to able to avoid taking damage from my team, either gaining enough block, or having good moves to evade those who could do damage. I had several hurt people and was playing more defensive. I clearly was not positioning people well. The limits added certainly make it extra difficult. Personally, I'm not that good at the game, so after going through 3 other phases, the extra boosts to the boss and limits on your available options made it less fun for me. For those who like this style more it probably works well. I know it is classic in RPGs to have the final boss go through multiple stages and get more powerful, so it does fit. It is just my own skill that makes an already tough fight go just far enough beyond where I my skill allows it to be fun. I did play on the default difficulty. In the future I will try the easier one.
Both winning and losing:
Making a note to delay winning until the start of your turn or something. And add more boolean toggles to events/popups. e.g. by default they shouldn’t be able to trigger if you’ve lost (and probably not if you’ve won)
Polearm popup: Maybe if they don’t turn her the first turn they have her, there’ll be a popup next turn.
9 turns on first fight is pretty normal. But if it still took multiple attempts for you who knows the mechanics from playing before, it’s probably still too hard.
Buttons: Adding a close button to the pause menu was something another playtester suggested late in the jam. I’m going to have a consistent position and look for close/resume button. Good to know they need to be more visible, though.
Mechanics reference: I’m kinda leery about adding too much stuff to any header, or adding too many headers, or having multiple headers that could plausibly contain the same info. I have an idea for how to do that, though.
Get Ready on someone with Trip: that should absolutely work. The only thing that prevents Get Ready is being out of range (which would also prevent it from popping up at all), or if you have too few Commands left. I’ll add a system for indicating why an action can’t be taken. Put a red highlight around the costs you can’t pay on the ability and/or the status effect that is preventing it. Should be pretty straightforward to do.
Extra damage before Endgame starts: I’m fine with people dealing damage before the limit appears, that’s kinda why I made the Endgame phase start at full health now instead of 5, so that I don’t need to specially give the boss invincibility, or begin Endgame immediately. Spending 1 Command to deal 1 damage usually isn’t really worth it when the boss starts at full health, but I want people to come to their own conclusions about how to play the game once they understand the mechanics.
Difficulty in the Endgame: I'm probably going to change Endgame a bit. There’s a some ludonarrative dissonance in how Endgame affects people even outside the map at the same strength (it’s not like a magic aura or something, it’s just meant to represent the fighting getting too frantic for people to rest and defend properly.)
Also probably have people cure Hurt if they stay in reserves for a while. I want to avoid situations where. Whenever someone gets Hurt, you spend effort to evacuate them, thus neglecting to defend your other characters. You end up in the Endgame with nobody dead, everyone Hurt and at low health, and now it's kinda hopeless.
That said, character death is an expected part of the story in Hardcore mode, and this first fight (though it’s a nonlethal spar) is meant to give the player the expectation that they can’t always save everyone.
While I have played before, and do know the basics, the core strategy for the game is not one that works well in my brain. It takes me a bit to really get my brain to think in terms of how the game works, and the need to largely rely on reactions. On the default difficulty it is certainly still very hard, and likely too hard for players who are not fans of this style of game. For the target audience, it is probably fine. I think that adding the easier difficulty was a good choice and will help with jam players who aren't as good. That easier difficulty may need additional tweaking, but I wouldn't go too far on the hard difficulty. In the future you may want even want to have 3 difficulty levels with your ideal being the hardest, but starting at a midway point so the average player doesn't get too frustrated with the default, while those it is meant for can choose to step up.
I'm going to say that my issue with "Get Ready" was likely distance. They were a bit away and I missed the range limit on it. Adding a notification as to why it isn't usable, though, would be helpful.
There is a lot to learn to be good at the game. Each version is making it easier to learn and get into the game. Finding the right balance of informing players, but not overwhelming them can be tough, but it feels like things are heading in the right direction.
Interesting game! I tried fairly hard, though, and couldn't beat the first level, so maybe this is a bit too hard. :) I managed to make some progress by repeatedly bracing one turn, then moving out and back into their threat region so they have to move and take my reaction attack the next turn. The thing where you take a debuff and then start losing health every turn put a bit of a spanner into this though, and when I felt like I had finally got it and thought I had killed the guy, it seemed like a second enemy jumped in to the fight?
You're not the only one to have problems with it. From my side, I kinda expected people to die in the tutorial and restart it, but it seems like it's hard enough to make multiple people quit, so I've already started making a few changes. Such as a full heal at the start of the second phase.
It sounds like you pretty much understand how to beat the first phase. The full heal would probably have helped a lot.
Did you catch the bit of the tutorial where it says status effects have tooltips? If not, I can make it a bit more obvious that you're supposed to check the status effect on the card.
Also, the new character is friendly, maybe I can make that a bit clearer too.
I wondered about that (whether the new character might be on my side), but I couldn't seem to be able to select them. It also seemed like their threat areas were being rendered the same coloured as the other enemy (but I might be wrong about that). Having an easier first fight is probably a good idea, maybe, with some kind of checkpoint after an initial short fight so you don't have to repeat the tutorial part.
I released a version making the tutorial easier yesterday. First section slightly easier, second section significantly easier and there's a full heal in between.
The threat area of the new character being red instead of orange feels really unlikely, that's never happened before. (If you try the game again and see it, maybe send me a picture. And tell me if you otherwise have difficulty telling apart the colors.) The colors change a bit when characters have no reactions left, but they're still very different to my eyes.
You right click (or click outside the board) to deselect. The tutorial says to right click, but I can see why you'd miss it, since it's at the end of a kinda long textbox that you have to close to keep playing. I got a few ideas for how to make that harder to miss + make it work on platforms that don't have a right click key.
Checkpoint system is on my radar and I think I can do some neat things with it for the second level. It's just something that can easily end up pretty fragile / with a lot of stuff I have to manually check, so it'll take a bit of work.
Dont understand enemy attack patterns at first time. Only when hover over left side cards notice what actually attack pattern will be.
Tutorials feel good.
Lose first battle :/