Hello, congratulations on being ranked #1 for the writing jam! Please send an e-mail to customers@onepagerules.com for us to follow up with you and send you the prize minis. Please let us know in the subject line of your placement and make sure to include a link to your submissions so we can easily identify you. Thanks.
Play book
An Apple, Unremembered's itch.io pageResults
| Criteria | Rank | Score* | Raw Score |
| Concepts & Originality | #1 | 4.469 | 4.469 |
| Flow & Clarity | #1 | 4.125 | 4.125 |
| Overall | #1 | 4.219 | 4.219 |
| Adherence to Theme | #2 | 4.062 | 4.062 |
Ranked from 32 ratings. Score is adjusted from raw score by the median number of ratings per game in the jam.
Comments
Hey, I'm going to narrate some of the entries from this jam and put them on YouTube, would it be alright if I did yours? I'd credit you of course. And congrats on first place!
Wonderful story. Touching on a faction that I don't see often. The quiet moments between battles. What does a creature that used to dream think about, after all they can no longer dream. Loved the description of the castle with bedrooms for the undead. Great work!
Excellent command of prose in this one, the lyrical presentation really fits the mood of longing and remembrance in the story.
Does Mary know what red is? This story is a great illustration of a philosophical puzzle. I'm not sure about the significance of the ending but perhaps it isn't for to know. Either way, great story!
This is a quiet piece, but it trusts the reader more than most quiet pieces do. The theme is not announced too loudly; it is carried through restraint, small gestures, and what the story chooses not to explain.
The strongest part, for me, is the control of detail. The writing understands that a small physical action can carry more weight than a direct statement. That gives the piece a sad, precise texture without making it feel sentimental.
My small nitpick is probably tied to the one-page constraint. Some of the emotional beats feel slightly compressed, especially around the dialogue. I think the story is strong enough that a little more breathing room between exchanges would make the impact cleaner.
thanks for reading.
i agree, my piece is subtle for the most part, though i think you’re being more generous than it probably deserves. and yeah, the breathing room note is sweet. one-page constraint made me compress the dialogue a bit too much. i’ll keep that in mind if i revise it.
appreciate the feedback.
Not my cup of tea, but it locked me in from the start. The flow is infuriatingly smooth. Strong execution!
Genuinely a beautiful piece of fiction with some incredibly evocative writing. This is the type of thing that would get me excited to run out and buy a box of this faction just because I loved this story so much.
I was so happy to see this one as the first in my queue. Really loving the ongoing theme of quiet depravity thus far in this Jam.
Also that in 2 cases so far, what is impossible is truly impossible.
Loved the story, and especially the habitual side of the undead. Top points for originality!
A good story, I enjoyed reading it. Are you looking for any feedback?
Alright, these were my thoughts while reading:
I'd say the beginning could use a small rewrite. Since both the kid and Othmara are female it wasn't entirely clear to me who was meant when the sentence just used "she" to refer to them. So it seemed like the kid was coming out of a drain, then suddenly standing under the tree, then half-way stuck in the wall while also visibly dragging a sack behind her. And it only became clear when Othmara specifically had the knife in hand, and that only happened 2/3rds down the page.
When Othmara tries the apple, after the kid gets pushy, she has an internal reaction but the kid seems to react to it- it felt like there was a visible reaction missing that the child could notice.
thank you, this is really helpful. after a closer reread, i can see the opening needs a cleaner pass, especially around the pronouns, blocking, and knife placement. good point on the apple scene too. giving the child one clearer thing to react to would probably make that moment land better. appreciate you taking the time to spell this out.
Peak quiet fantasy right here!!
Written by someone who clearly loves literature, and I mean that kindly. There is this quiet pleasure in every sentence, every small detail doing more work than it should! And the apple carries the whole theme of impossible without ever being forced into it.
Gentle, sad, and very nicely put together.
Lovely work!!
Beautifully written story. I really loved the contrast between Len’s simple humanity and Othmara’s emotional emptiness, and the apple became a surprisingly powerful symbol throughout the piece. The atmosphere felt melancholic and reflective in a way that stayed with me long after the ending.



Leave a comment
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.