Sorry i did not got into that part, yet. But maybe try making an milk-shake i played the old preggoprixels lacto escape expanded, and the fairie wanted milk. Also if it is not the right recipe. Do an topic!

You gotta listen to what the fairy asks for. She gives 3 hints and you figure out which one it is.

Eg: She says, "and don't hold back on the sugar" = Add most amount of sugar