Now this is much easier to look at. π I reorganized everything without removing a single combination, so it still remains 13 Neutral + 27 Lizard + 32 Bull = 72 combinations.
I sorted them by the resulting [Lizards, Bulls] (L,B) values from smallest to largest: first by increasing L. and then, when L is the same, then increase the B.
As a reminder, the base numbers come from the Day 1β4 suspicion table: Day 1 gives L+2, B+2 or L+1; Day 2 gives L+3, B+3 or L+2βB+1 and L+1βB+2; Day 3 gives L+3, B+3, or L+2βB+2; and Day 4 gives β2 to one side.
Choice Codes
Day 1
A = save the Spy β (L0,B2)
B = meet Nauxus + kill the Spy β (L2,B0)
C = do not meet Nauxus + kill the Spy β (L1,B0)
Day 2
A = help the Bull β (L3,B0)
B = help the Lizard β (L0,B3)
C = say yes to Selye, then help Thane β (L2,B1)
D = say yes to Axel, then help Thane β (L1,B2)
Day 3
A = Bomb the Lizard β (L3,B0)
B = Recruit Rogue Lizards β (L0,B3)
C = Sabotage both β (L2,B2)
Day 4
A = give the fruit to the Bull β (L0,Bβ2)
B = give the fruit to the Lizard β (Lβ2,B0)
---
π’ NEUTRAL ROUTE — 13 combinations
#| Result L,B| D1| D2| D3| D4
1| 2,3| C| A| B| B
2| 2,3| C| B| A| B
3| 2,3| C| D| B| A
4| 3,2| C| C| B| A
5| 3,2| C| D| A| B
6| 3,3| A| A| B| A
7| 3,3| A| B| A| A
8| 3,3| A| C| A| B
9| 3,3| B| A| B| B
10| 3,3| B| B| A| B
11| 3,3| B| D| B| A
12| 3,3| C| B| C| A
13| 3,3| C| C| C| B
So the Neutral results are neatly grouped into:
2,3 β 3,2 β 3,3
---
π¦ LIZARD ROUTE — 27 combinations
#| Result L,B| D1| D2| D3| D4
1| β2,8| A| B| B| B
2| β1,6| C| B| B| B
3| β1,7| A| D| B| B
4| 0,5| C| D| B| B
5| 0,6| A| B| B| A
6| 0,6| A| C| B| B
7| 0,6| B| B| B| B
8| 0,7| A| B| C| B
9| 1,4| C| B| B| A
10| 1,4| C| C| B| B
11| 1,5| A| A| B| B
12| 1,5| A| B| A| B
13| 1,5| A| D| B| A
14| 1,5| B| D| B| B
15| 1,5| C| B| C| B
16| 1,6| A| D| C| B
17| 2,4| A| C| B| A
18| 2,4| A| D| A| B
19| 2,4| B| B| B| A
20| 2,4| B| C| B| B
21| 2,4| C| D| C| B
22| 2,5| A| B| C| A
23| 2,5| A| C| C| B
24| 2,5| B| B| C| B
25| 3,4| A| A| C| B
26| 3,4| A| D| C| A
27| 3,4| B| D| C| B
Notice the interesting pattern: all of them have L < B, which corresponds to the Lizard Route.
---
π BULL ROUTE — 32 combinations
Now this is the largest one. All 32 combinations are still included.
#| Result L,B| D1| D2| D3| D4
1| 4,1| C| A| B| A
2| 4,1| C| B| A| A
3| 4,1| C| C| A| B
4| 4,2| A| A| A| B
5| 4,2| A| D| A| A
6| 4,2| B| C| B| A
7| 4,2| B| D| A| B
8| 4,2| C| A| C| B
9| 4,2| C| D| C| A
10| 4,3| A| C| C| A
11| 4,3| B| B| C| A
12| 4,3| B| C| C| B
13| 5,0| C| A| A| B
14| 5,0| C| D| A| A
15| 5,1| A| C| A| A
16| 5,1| B| A| B| A
17| 5,1| B| B| A| A
18| 5,1| B| C| A| B
19| 5,1| C| C| C| A
20| 5,2| A| A| C| A
21| 5,2| B| A| C| B
22| 5,2| B| D| C| A
23| 6,β1| C| C| A| A
24| 6,0| A| A| A| A
25| 6,0| B| A| A| B
26| 6,0| B| D| A| A
27| 6,0| C| A| C| A
28| 6,1| B| C| C| A
29| 7,β2| C| A| A| A
30| 7,β1| B| C| A| A
31| 7,0| B| A| C| A
32| 8,β2| B| A| A| A
And the pattern is clear: B < L, so they fall into the Bull Route.
---
π Summary of all 72 combinations
Route| Number of combinations| Result range
π’ Neutral| 13| 2,3 β 3,2 β 3,3
π¦ Lizard| 27| β2,8 β 3,4
π Bull| 32| 4,1 β 8,β2
π Selye| 0|
TOTAL| 72|
Selye does not appear among these 72 suspicion combinations because the Selye Route is triggered by the special condition of letting Thane die, rather than by comparing the Lizard/Bull points. The wiki explicitly explains that the Selye Route is a variant of the Lizard Route that is achieved by allowing Thane to die.
So now the table can truly be used as a βlist of all 72 possibilitiesβ: simply look at your D1 β D4 choices, and you can immediately determine the resulting (L,B) score and the corresponding route.
So, if we apply the concept of an Eyvind multiverse, those 72 combinations can essentially be viewed as 72 distinct timelines, where the decisions Eyvind makes during the war determine how each clan perceives him.
The Selye Route, meanwhile, can be considered a special timeline outside that 72-scenario system, since its branching point hinges on Thane's fate rather than the distribution of suspicion between the two clans.
