I found it pretty challenging managing the potion creation and keeping Papa alive until he started chugging (spoiler). I reckon good call keeping the auto-battler easy-ish - it was nice to reach a stress-free point where Papa couldn't die, then sit back to enjoy all the artwork.
Play game
Potion Papa's itch.io pageRate this game
Sign up with an itch.io account to rate and leave comments.
Comments
i love the artstyle, it’s very nice!
to me the autobattler part feels very disconnected from the main gameplay, and it’s easy to just forget about because it’s, well, auto, and just get distracted mixing all the potions until you realise “wait i’m about to die” and there’s nothing you can do. i think it should have a bigger presence in the game, or at least have some feedback about what’s happening that isn’t just confined to the menu on the right.
it also felt like there just wasn’t much of a reason to experiment with the potion brewing – (afaict) each ingredient just gives a flat boost and there isn’t really a reason to try and combine different ingredients to make something like a super powered potion because of the synergy between them. i think it would be fun if combining certain ingredients (like slime + roe, because they’re both health related, or mushroom and iron because they both help with offsense, etc.) would make more powerful potions, because right now it just doesn’t feel like there’s much of a reason to make anything other than combining the same ingredient twice.
it would also be if there was more strategy to when you drink potions, the health potion is a good example of this. i think it would be fun to have to stock up buffs before an especially powerful boss approaches. offensive potions could also help play into that some more.
i also agree with the other comment that it’s way too easy to out-scale the enemies, especially with silver.
these things are just something to keep in mind if you want to expand the game or for some future games, and are likely out of scope of a jam. it’s still a great game and i had a lot of fun!
Thanks for playing our game! We didn’t have enough time for proper playtesting and balancing, so I skewed the auto-battler on the easier side of things so that jam players could get a chance to experience all the minigames and art that my teammates designed, but that led to Papa eventually becoming essentially unkillable at a certain point. You could always try a self imposed challenge run where you only use slime for healing if you wanted a challenge!
There’s no proper ending to the game, with the goal just being to get as far as possible, with gold acting as a final score, though with the balancing issues mentioned earlier it does lead to a runaway economy. But I guess eternal life and infinite gold is what the alchemists wanted, right?







Leave a comment
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.