Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

You must be 18+ to view this content

Celestiel may contain content you must be 18+ to view.

The creator of this page has specified that it contains mature themes and content. Please enter your birthdate to verify you are 18 or older:

or Return to itch.io

Celestiel

A collectible card game featuring size changing. · By CelesTheCreator

Some general feedback on cards/ballance.

A topic by terricon4 created 11 days ago Views: 200 Replies: 7
Viewing posts 1 to 7

Ok, playing several games against a few decks... my thoughts are the ballance is rather anti grow/size play, despite that being the mechanic/idea. If you want to go forrest and buff big cards, you'll lose to water and light decks almost automaticly.

Key examples of cards that just deny the growth/power play style of forrest deck. Standardize Action, Torrential Flow, Tidal whirlpool, or Radiant Blast.
These are cards that just auto delete one enemy, or remove it to the players hand. 
You can try to build a Flowering Dryad, it'll probably never stay alive long enough to matter,  or a Verdant Dryad, probably off the field before it's even able to attack in a turn. The problem cards each cost like 2 energy to play, making them insanely effective counters against anything expensive. And if you drop one follower onto the field, and then toss a bigify or hugify or two onto them... you might be losing 3+ cards, 3 full turns of drawing, to a single enemy card and one of their turns of drawing. Even if they just push it back into your hand, that's letting them get attacks through in that turn, and you lose the buff cards entirely, and then have to pay to re deploy them the next turn just to wait another turn for them to do anything. Against decks with those cards, I think I won maybe one in eight games while trying to make a competitve growth deck.

These auto kill/hand cards are extremely powerful, yet right now extremely cheap and you can have many of them in your deck. Every time I'm trying to do any green decks looking for size/growth mechanic as an idea, I lose if the enemy is a water or sunlight mix in their decks.. Only answer is to just spam smaller general things or the new medium frogs, or use other deck types.

Overall I think any card that can hand or exhaust someone should have a clear size or power limit, or be extremely expensive itself, or have some other penalty.

In addition, larger/powerful cards should have something more they can do. When I can have a pair of large expensive cards, and the enemy drops a caring bunny and one other familiar card, both my cards are blocked on the bunny duo, while I will still lose character health to the other one. And two turns of a 3 cost harpy can kill verdant dryad that costs six, lots of cheaper/mid cards have really good stats, compared to expensive ones that aren't that impresive given that there's no allowed overkill, or blocking from being a big or expensive card. A single large high power card does very little other than kill one enemy at a time, and most cards have power already around health levels so lower level cards do this as well in many cases. More realisticly, I drop down one big card for 7 points, they drop 3 cheap ones, for the same or even less and I just lose as my character takes the hits and it takes two turns before I can even clear out one of theirs. Size should have "splash" damage that can start hittng multiple enemies, if less efficiently, or to big to get past that stops enemies from getting past them. Or beyond a certain size difference attacks against them have a debuff... Larger cards need something, because right now... I can't make any growth focused decks work against a lot of enemy deck types, even after messing with them several times. Big things aren't great on their own, and the time/investment to play them means smaller cheaper builds will have probably killed you well before now (bunny spam with the sheep growth buff is insane), and there are even those hard counter cards that just 100% stop them from even working on the rare cases they otherwise might have had a chance with lucky pulls bringing them out early enough.

On the semi opposite side, Sullen Shrooms ability to negate enemy power of ALL smaller cards than them is just insane against many sun deck builds, her plus any growth buffs and you can see her debuff a rabit/snake/shroom/fairy/etc... list by -10 damage all of them each turn. When they can completely invalidate an entire enemy formation just dropping in and maybe getting a buff, that seems pretty OP at the moment, especially for their cost. Somewhat situational don't get me wrong, but good luck killing them if the monster on your side paired up against them at the front where small ones. Even if you mix smaller and a big or two, because of how the formation attacking mechanic works they might be entirely safe from your bigger enemies till they themselves kill through your smaller front row to them or something.

Also possible bug, have noticed that the location of some familairs/characters on screen doesn't always match up with the visual, so you might click on one, yet get the one next to it. Feels like it gets worse as the game goes on, or maybe it's just the more expensive forrest cards that have it, though not sure, but it is a sometimes issue sometimes not thing. Will try to figure that out more reliably when I got more fre etime. Messed away tonight testing how large I could get a familar, and it's a couple kilometers, though could go any size with enough time/patience, though can't see anything then given zoom out limits, already kinda hit that limit it felt like.

Overall, games gettign goodish, and definitely has some interest to be had, and a lot of potential. So I'm more actively looking forward to future builds after messing around this free night. Oh, and a request on a feature would be a log that shows what cards the enemy has played, or abilities activated that affected anything of your own. Had a good few cases when speed is set hight to keep it playable in time, that something happened and I missed it and just lost two or three of my familiars at once when I glanced down to look at my own cards and think about my next turn or something.

Developer

Hey Terricon4,

Thanks for the comment, I really appreciate you taking the time to go in depth.

For the anti-growth/big playstyle. Yup there is a kind of weird meta between big followers, small followers, and actions that exhaust them. Big followers beat small followers and only get taken down once enough small followers have attempted to tussle with them, small followers beat most of the actions that exhaust them by being at a similar cost, having effects, or by having a trigger that leaves them with value even after getting removed, and actions beat those bigger followers, but normally have a downside when they do counter them, such as torrential flow only stalling, or radiant blast rotting in your hand and being very niche in its use. Small followers also have the really big weakness of being easy to clean up with flame trail or obsidian star, so there is some play in all regards. Big followers also do have the ability to rip and tear character lilumi really quickly and if they don't get answered they either grow out of control and win (like flowering alraune who sometimes grows to 100ft+ while other followers try to block it from dealing massive damage to your character), or take up multiple cards to deal with. At this point, most of the big followers like verdant dryad are more on the basic side as they are just uncommon cards so they do get countered by cards like radiant blast, or get stalled against cards like torrential flow but that is just certain essences do have better answers to big followers than others. The good news is that growth based cards that are more effective against those type of cards, either because they don't need to be buffed, or they do something regardless of if they get removed will come in the future to hopefully solidify those types of decks further!

Big followers having splash damage is a good idea, I do have it slated later in my build path just because I noticed that the AI wasn't taking it into account properly when I developed it earlier causing them to make some really weird plays.

Speaking of the Lambie, Bunnykin combo, I ran a couple thousand games now that the simulator is 100% built and yup, Lambie is just way too powerful, she's getting a nerf in the next build as her win rate was way too high, so hopefully that will weaken that strategy as the only real answer to her is flame trail and obsidian star, but even when countering her, it just brings you to a more even playing field. Especially in Lambie decks that had Caring Bunnykin, where starting with a Caring Bunnykin in hand would instantly raise your win rate by 10%+.

Sullen Shroom is a fun card, it more of a combo based card where you grow the sullen shroom and it completely stifles the follower power and turns them into dead weight. It is kind of hard to get off but fun when it happens. Sadly sullen shroom doesn't have too high of a win rate but it gives water and nature decks an actual way to deal with bunnykin swarms.

For the possible bug, I think this is caused when in certain UI modes such as either Tight or Stacked mode. Especially if the followers get too big and start to slightly overlap with each other. I'm hoping to test that further myself but I think that is what I am leaning towards the issue being. The most noticable is when you have an absolutely massive flowering alraune and can't click your character anymore. I'm hoping to either fix that, or add shortcuts so you can activate abilities using your keyboard as well.

Good news for the next build! You will hopefully never hit the zoom out limit again. I think it goes up to 160m in build 0.04.0 currently? I'm hoping by cranking that up to 10^30+ meters (which is some number of trillions of lightyears?), the zoom out limit should no longer be an issue. I know that's something I was playing with a lot.

Yup a log is a good idea, I'll add it to my build list so I can eventually get to it. Funnily enough programming it ain't the hardest, the hardest thing is actually figuring out where to fit it on the screen.

Thank you for the great information!

(4 edits)

Honestly didn't feel much like larger beat smaller to me. Smaller is normally out before bigger, so when you summon a bigger it gets hit twice before it's own hit, so a verdant dryad against a harpy healer will just have both die. And in that time you've already got extra character damage happening from any other smalls sent out. Big only seemed to counter small when both players seemed to have mostly essence/etc... non familiars in their starting hands, and it took several turns before anything actually started coming onto the field, and there wasn't extra cards in hand for multiple plays and it was down to drawing speed where bigger stuff would win being more value dense per card. But that was rarely what happened. (EDIT: Played a few more games in some spare time this morning, tried other decks/unit types, and ok, some small types are beaten by some larger types, though there are several of the smaller ones that do seem to scale really well like harpy healer, but the low damage zero snooze time ones do indeed fail against large enemies that tank and just kill them in return, wasn't using many of those in my own builds, and enemies only a bit also). Still bias towards the current powerful smaller ones win over the current big ones in most cases, but not as extreme after more testing as I initially figured.

On the growth side, beyond the flowering alruane didn't really feel like anything was particularly viable. That was the one exception it felt like. Otherwise anything beyond dropping one biggify onto a random monster to keep it alive long enough to get a hit in just felt too costly for what it offered. This was the "growth" play I was more or less mentioning in my post to clarify, as in buffing size of my own familiars, whatever they might have been (little lamia, verdant dryad, or anything else I tried), the only one that ever sorta worked was the flowering allrune. But even then, a single counter card and it's just gone for 2 vigor cost.

Had a number of ideas for complex formulas for damage scaling/aoe/etc... relative to size differences, but in the end for that just scaling default values seems far better on the playability size, like larger familiars having a bit more health base so they don't just die easily. Having players do (attacker familiar size divided by defending familiar size) divided by ten, clamped result 0 to 1. Times (attacker power - defender health) to figure out over penetration dmg was just kinda silly feeling. And some familars have size, being upright standing, more relative to power over others... so sticking with the power/health values is probalby best for most things.

For AOE the simplest mechanical idea that's intuitive and doesn't require a bunch of math from the player was just to have punch through, after an attack happens, the left over damage is cut in half, rounded down, and continues onto the next target. Maybe cut in quarter or third if needed for ballance but the idea of keeping it simple, yet still letting a cheap thing in the front absorb a good bit of the hit.

Main thing that comes to mind as the thing to look into shorter term is figuring out maybe a system for dynamic cost cards. Like Radiant blast costing 2+2X to use against a given target, with X being the targets power/health or something divided by 10 or so, rounded up. So its at cost 4 expensive against smaller cards, still not great there, but not too cheap against a heavily buffed power 40 verdant dryad, yet still comparatively a cost effective counter even if it now costs 10 to activate against such a card. Or be where you pick the spend and it does that times a given damage value to the target, so even if you can't one shot a big thing, you can cripple it. Same with AOE fire cards, be like 2+X energy, with X being the number of enemy familiars/entities it will hit, so if they have 8 bunnies up, it wont insta kill it all, but for 6 energy can still kill 4 of them for example. Just the idea of basic locks like this that keep a card from doing infinite value regardless of the situation on the board, for a flat (and often very low) fixed cost. Same thing with stomp, despite being part of my intended deck in all that playing oddly only ever used it once or twice. But in theory a limit on stomping say the first X familiars relative to your combined size difference might be good, like only applies to the first X familiars that total size added up isn't combined greater than your own largest one or something.

And the bunnykin, I think the lamb skill of grow/buff all summons regardless of number for only 4 is kinda OP itself, most others have very limited abilities that are often single target for the same cost. So giving her a restriction or scaling cost might help as well. But the bunnykin are I think the main problem. For 1 cost you can drop down two familiars, turn one that's 2. Turn 2 that's 6, with two attacking, if you get the right starting hand. Unless the opponent is fire with the right cards available, there's no coming back from that. Numbers right now are just way too strong against big familiars again, until you hit endgame where cards become more limited by draw rate. Either the bunnies should have like 0 power, only health/tanking, and bunnykin like 1 or 2, or they should cost more or something. Though against with penetrating/AOE attacks this might  be helped as well, just right now, this card alone feels like the best in the game.

Developer (1 edit)

Could you confirm what is happening with harpy healer vs verdant dryad? Because the way you are describing it I actually think it might be bugged on the build. Verdant Dryad should never die to a Harpy Healer as followers should always counter attack when hit. So if a harpy tussles a dryad, it'll deal 8 damage, take 12 back and immediately get exhausted on that same turn leaving the dryad alive, and the same if the dryad tussles first, it will exhaust the harpy and then take back 8 damage and live with 7 lilumi. Just want to make sure a bug is not inadvertently making big followers way weaker then they are supposed to be.

Flowering Alraune is definitely the best of them, the next build does have a couple other growth based followers that are cheaper that you can build around and I'll be adding better ones in the future as I add the higher rarity cards. I think one of the big issues is that because cards like radiant blast are very niche, they get stuck in the character's hand since they have nothing to use it on so it kind of makes it seem like they have it more often than they proportionally should. Once I give the ability to have multiple rares of the same kind in the deck, cards like flowering alraune will be more consistent as not only will you just have more of them, but you'll also be able to overload the ability for the opposing character to have answers as they only run so many in their deck.

Bunnykin do have a high win rate in my testing simulations, but it's absolutely much worse in Lambie's deck as her ability is just way too good with the bunnykins as well as just really strong in general. The notes I have from thousands of simulation games show me that her signature card Fluffy Presence is below average and her ability is really strong, it's actually already nerfed for the 0.05.0 build.

Thanks  for your feedback!

Still not 100% sure on that, went over the tutorial again in full (didn't skip any) yesterday to make sure I'd gotten all the rules figured since a few parts I wasn't fully clear on. And was wondering how those cases were happening where I was seemingly taking a hit while my own familiar was inactive, or they just weren't reacting since in other testing even on delay a familar seems to react when tussling. Makes me wonder if there was a wall or other card/skill in effect on some of those, but not recalling anything visually on the field for it on several cases other than the harpy (or something in front of it we didn't hit either), though with no log another played card or ability might have been affecting things, as I was still less familar with all of them at that point. Do plan to try to figure that out alongside some other things with more testing, have to put them back in my decks (mostly removed them on the general play ones after ten or so games with them). And do screen recording to make sure I don't miss anything that happened after the fact. Memory can be unreliable at times.

Though am curious on the exact rules of tussels.
By my understanding, if you are active/off delay, in your own attack phase you will have a familiar attack the first non tusseled (yet attacked) enemy familiar thats active. Lastly character if only option.
Then once attacked, if it is a familar, even if power is 0, it will return attack the first non attacked entity on your side.
The tutorial just says familairs wont attack a tusseled entity, but then say your first familiar is a wall, it attacks the enemy first (a bunny), that bunny then react attacks into the wall right? So now your third entity, another familiar has its attack, it attacks the enemy second familiar, the hostile second familiar now finds the first non tusseled entity on your side and... attacks your second familiar right? Despite it already initiating a tussle? The tutorial description felt a bit innacurate/brief there I think unless I"m mis remembering it.

Though this also leads me to question how a splash damage option would work, unless its an ability and not part of the default attack logic like the overpenetration example I gave previously. It it is, but just doesn't trigger any reaction to it specificly.

Add notes for familiar/entity/etc... category so you know what a card is/can be affected by, as while many like walls feel somewhat intuitive, it has been a point of confusion at times on why an ability didn't seem to do anything to something.

Developer

I'm wondering that maybe it may have been an issue with the build or possibly there was a structure in a way that blocked the tussle back. I do see it in the tutorial text but who knows, I may have to look at it further if the wording in the tutorial is not intuitive enough. An eventual log should hopefully clear that up better.

Yup. So any entity that tussles or gets tussled will be a tussled entity until the end of that turn and won't be tussled twice. So in the scenario of:
Marigold - Dryad - <> - Wall - Harpy - Lambie (Note this logic is accurate as of 0.04.0).
In this scenario, if all entities are active (meaning they are not darkened and don't have the sleep symbol), and it is the harpies turn:
1) The wall will take its turn and do nothing as it is a structure, it has not tussled so it is still an allowed tussle target.
2) The harpy will take its turn and deal 8 damage to the dryad, the dryad will tussle the first entity it can, which will be the wall.
3) The harpy, dryad, and wall will all be marked as tussled, meaning any future tussles can't involve them. They will have a red indicator above their dormant that shows that.
4) The wall will be exhausted as it has no lilumi left.

For the splash damage option, it will likely tussle a target as normal and deal damage to other entities, but only the primary entity would tussle back.

I'll double check the tutorial for terminology on card types. It is a little confusing since each card type fits in another card type holder though some of them are not really given or talked about.
Object (Not seen in game) - Anything that can exist on the field in some way such as characters, entities, and accessories.
Entity - Followers and Structures.
Accessory - Relics and Auroras.

Thanks for the feedback I appreciate you!

Well, got in a few more play sessions, but haven't noticed any of that case of attacks hitting familiars who are not yet active, or those active not yet attacking back.
So for now I'll put that down to possibly a bug, or just me mis identifying parts of the game happening while still new to it.

Though I do still very much have most of my bigger characters just die or get handed in most fights from an action/reaction/ability etc... so that part's still not changed...  But the possible bug is... at least not something I'm currently finding over the past three sessions I played.

Developer

Well that's good that at least the bug isn't reproducible so maybe it was corrected or a misbug from a previous version.

Yeah the thing with the big characters are they either need to be exhausted quickly, or they do just exhaust the character and end the battle in a very short time frame. Enjoy your sessions.