Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Idol Manager

Idol Manager is a business sim about conquering the entertainment industry using any means you deem necessary. · By sadambober, Kuiper

Ideas and Suggestions Sticky

A topic by sadambober created Nov 20, 2018 Views: 62,749 Replies: 454
Viewing posts 241 to 260 of 311 · Next page · Previous page · First page · Last page
(+1)

I was thinking it would be interesting to have a feature where you could buy other idol production companies and absorb them into your group. Maybe have policies set where the idols you get from "buying out" the company either become a sister group or they are managed autonomously and you get a cut of the revenue instead of all of it by taking direct control of the group.

Also, it would be nice if you could set policies for all groups or have different policies for differ sister groups.

(+3)

Hi I am a new purchaser here

Loving the game so far! Lots of good potential and fun.

I have  beta 19 feedback (directly dealing with this version's concerns) after playing for almost a solid day now:

  • The interface that notifies us that the idol stamina is a bit tiny... it'd be cool if you have some sort of key or feature that allows us to quickly see the detailed status of the idols that are important to us (especially since some of them are quite needy)
  • Better notification system would be super beneficial since it is easy to forget the tasks that are done when playing in a super productive manner (a suggestion I have is to use a notification dot system i.e. red dot for things that are done, yellow dot for things that need our reply such as when managers land deals etc)
  • It gets confusing when trying to choose the stylist in terms of which skill they are best at... can we have some sort of way to customize it for example a sexy/cool stylist can be designated <insert> color? It would also be beneficial for the other roles too so we don't confuse between production and coaching
  • Speaking of coaching, wouldn't it be good to have rooms for education? That way idols can improve their smart and funny stats similar to how they can improve their vocal and dance skills
  • To expand on the above, it could be pretty cool if they also have better chances of getting bonus stars during world tours if they have a higher stat... because so far getting 5 stars in any country is pretty darn hard or at the very least super unclear
  • Currently it is extremely difficult to get any single promotion for the employees... perhaps it is okay to make the growth rate of the employees a bit faster?
  • Some of the achievements are quite troublesome to achieve especially the 6 maxed out stats because idols lose stats as they age and the training time to get some of those back to 100 is tough
  • I think that the manager should have an option of focusing on landing certain types of deals (sexy/cute/pretty/cool) because sometimes, trying to land a specific gig takes years... it also makes sense if we are intending to focus on a specific market but to not have control of this is kind of strange
  • It can be hard to earn money in this game without the Y button haha would it be a good idea to create a merchandise section in the building (similar to how companies do it in real life) in order to have a section that is providing constant base income (I mean we are providing a salary, but there is no constant stream of cash despite making a portfolio)?
  • It would be a very attractive feature to be able to allow us to change the portrait styles of an idol in game (as in, we can change their hair color and type etc) like a simple version of sims when visiting the stylist... people love customization and it isn't going to hurt to have different new skins and styles as DLC content on steam in the future (rather than finding the save file to change stuff up)

Should I make another post on things not related to version 19 but still ideas on the game overall?

Developer

>focusing on landing certain types of deals (sexy/cute/pretty/cool)

You can select Policies -> Vibe and it should affect proposals too. Or are you already doing that and it's still to hard?

>Should I make another post on things not related to version 19 but still ideas on the game overall?

Yeah, of course!

Hi Sadambober,

  • Yea it still takes time even after selecting policies and stuff, the RNG can force me to take a long time to wait to strike the right requirement for some reason... seeing as it is 1/4 it shouldn't be so bad I thought but yea it can be...
  • Actually RNG in general is strange because on my first run through of the game, I made a sister group and encountered a situation where I just never got a gold or black card no matter how many auditions I did (also abandoned that save file due to this issue)... Is that a known problem? 

I will play the game some more and then reply back for those ideas. Thank you once again for making this game. I think that it has really good potential!

Developer(+1)

>never got a gold or black card no matter how many auditions I did

Maybe you had too many scandal points? If you hover over the number of your scandal points at the bottom, the tooltip should say if you have any "debuffs"

(+2)

It's be cool if

You could hype up digital releases (as let's be honest when was the last time you bought an actual music CD). In my opinion, hardcopy CDs should be more popular among hardcore fans as it could be considered "merch."

(2 edits)

I think hardcopy CDs are still reeeaaally big in Japan. Still, more promo options for digital releases would be cool- they wouldn't even need to be free, you would still be paying for the advertising, which keeps the balance of only having one no-cost marketing option.

(+1)

Also, the event where someone pretends to be one of your idols and you send a cease-and-desist, it'd be nice to have a follow up option to sue the imposter.

(+1)

Another awesome idea is to have the option to mock the imposter similarly to how we do this with the politicians ahahah

(+3)

Have you debated adding the ability to compile albums in any length? I feel like it could be an advantage to either wrap old singles together into an album, or spend more time and resource to create an album instead of a single.

By wrapping the previous sigles into an album, it may also create a convenient way to select a song if you wanted a specific lead for a concert!

(3 edits) (+3)

Gonna offer up that going from "reach level 2 of promotion" (ie release a first single) to "top the monthly sales chart" (ie sell over a million copies) as requirements for two sequential story beats is way too tall of an order for players since million sellers don't happen within your first year of play unless you REALLY speedrun it and play optimally (Even then it would take a dozen singles or several months and TV drama upgrades to get a million seller)

(Also I get wanting to keep the new features and systems fresh but I'd like to know what they are if I'm supposed to play the game this long to get to the next story part. I was interested in what the new features are but the chart-topper requirement was enough to put me off trying to experience it.)

Developer (1 edit)

You only need ~100,000 sales for this task, so it shouldn't be THAT bad. There are no major new gameplay features, they are more like cute little things you can discover.

(If you really don't want to do this, you can just cheat and F7 -> "Complete all tasks")

(+1)

"You only need ~100,000 sales for this task, so it shouldn't be THAT bad"

hmm well in my game the #1 has never dipped below 900k each month. Is this just a bug on my end?

Developer

Could be a bug or just bad luck. These million sellers should be rare in the early game

(+1)

more than luck, I've been playing the beta since fall of 2019 and the chart topper is consistently a million seller, or near a million over all save files.

Developer

Yeah, it was like that, but should be different now, at least in story mode

I was worried I'd get stuck there because I'd been seeing million sellers topping the list up to that point, but the next month I hit the top of the chart with 200k or so, so I think it's fixed to ensure you get it

(+2)

I don't know if this is a bug or what, but I'm well over a year into my group in story mode and I can not get more than 50k sales tops. Even doing money cheats so I could fire all of the staff and replace them with the highest ranked producer/choreographer/marketing I can't hit the tops sales position and it's a little ridiculous. I actually kind of forgot there was a story mode because it's been so long in game since I've been able to advance it.

(+1)

It took me one to two in-game years and several real life days to move from chapter 1 to chapter 2, and then I went from chapter 2 to chapter 5 in one night. It was odd.

I'm afraid the 'Continue' button in the Main Menu might cause some confusion now that we have two game modes. Maybe it could be beneficial to add some sort of indicator that would allow players to know whether they'd be loading a Story Mode save or a Free Play save upon clicking on 'Continue'.

(+1)

Honestly, it would be better to get rid of weird/nonstandard setup introduced in this update...  On the home screen should be "new game" and "load game"...  "New Game" would offer a choice of modes, and under "load game" the individual save files would show their mode, dates, etc...

(1 edit) (+1)

Some issues I am finding with the new build: 

1.) The "random photo" is still on some idols you can hire. Considering this is no longer in the game...(at least Idt it is) not sure if you need to change the bonus or not.  And one idol I did have that had this bonus, said that "negations for photographs are always successful." However, when I "negotiating" it kept failing. I am not sure if this feature was for the assistant who makes the deals or what...but that maybe confusing to new plays who think it's referring to the negotiation button. 

2.) Can we PLEASE have a way to advertise digital releases? I remember back in the old builds, we had  this ability (with the fake scandals, etc.) I don't even bother with them anymore b/c unless it's the very beginning of the game when I'm broke, it doesn't help me build the idol group. 

3.) So, for the ad campaign, when I release some singles, the spinning wheel no longer pops up. On some releases, it does pop up. I'm sure it's a bug.  

4.) I like getting idols with lower stats and building them up (it's just the way I play :P I enjoy it). However, is there a way we can train the idols first before they debut? Like, have the ability to put an idol we hired under training and then do a "debut" campaign or something? This is just an idea that I am sure is not original buttttt I wanted to suggest it XD 

5.) I am enjoying the new build so far :) Keep up the good work! I am looking forward to the release. 

quote '4.) I like getting idols with lower stats and building them up (it's just the way I play :P I enjoy it). However, is there a way we can train the idols first before they debut? Like, have the ability to put an idol we hired under training and then do a "debut" campaign or something? This is just an idea that I am sure is not original buttttt I wanted to suggest it XD'

I personally use the sister group functionality for this. I create a 'trainee' group that keeps training until each of them have certain stats at a certain standard, then i move them into another group and let them debut. To get those extra groups i basically game the system by mass-hiring from local auditions to open up extra sister group functionality and firing those mass-hired ones after i created the necessary groups.

So it can be done via workaround currently but i fully agree it would be nice to have this as a common feature like a sister group for a prize in terms of money and limited functionality (no single releases, certain contracts cant be assigned to its members etc).

(1 edit) (+1)

Shouldn't the mods be bound with the save not the whole game?

Would it be better if the mods can be activated per start (when start a new game), while keeping the mod tab in the main menu screen for master activation?



because I would like to have different game saves for different mods, for example, save A for vanilla game, and save for K-Pop mod.

(7 edits) (+1)

Could we have an option to divorce? I know this is not a decent thing to do, but y'know, gameplay wise it kinda makes sense.

Also, R18 contents seemed too generic and non-interactive right now. The idol in R18 CGs could have layered facial features, hairstyles and clothing just like the standing pictures. And we could have more choices, routes and varieties in terms of R18 scenes and gameplay. I know it's not a dating sim, but it's always nice to have everything as detailed and developed as possible if decided to be implemented in the first place. The variety of aspects, possibilities and gameplay functionalities is one of the biggest strong points of this game IMO and I rate this game above all other similar titles simply because of this. I'd love to be surprised even more.

Edit: Some new thoughts. It doesn't make sense that the songs can't be produced simultaneously by the producer, manager, coach, etc. This is not realistic. Also, the collection of idols can be further expanded. After a while it gets pretty repetitive at current state.

Love the new stories and dating system tho. Keep up the great work.

(+1)

(WARNING: spoilers for the ending of the rival's route. I don't think itch has spoiler tags, unfortunately. Beware, those who have not finished the rival's route of the main story.)

1. Out of sheer morbid curiosity, I romanced an idol and then went on to pick the sex tape option for the rival route. I'm surprised that the idol I romanced didn't acknowledge it, and in the case of marrying her (which I assume means the relationship goes public), surprised that it wasn't more of a scandal or outright career-ender. Was that overlooked, or will it be added later, or was it not included for simplicity's sake?

2. This is more of a self-indulgent suggestion that might be out of the game's scope, but would it be possible to romance the rival? Maybe as a post-1.0 DLC or update? I find the rival's chemistry with the player incredibly compelling and I'd love to have something a bit more permanent than the apparent one-off at the end of the rival's route. Unless more rival events happen in chapter VII, in which case I'm a dunce.

3. Some of the idols' dialogue when you fail to influence them to delay graduation feel unnecessarily harsh. I had one accuse me of never caring about her, and that felt a bit over the top considering I had level 4 friendship with her. Just say you owe me nothing more lmao. Maybe the possible dialogue could be based on friendship and/or romance level? "You never cared about me anyway" feels a lot more appropriate if you only have level 0-1 relationship with the idol.

Lastly: I love this game so much. Even if you ignore all the above, I still think this is a damn good game with a damn good story.

Developer

>Some of the idols' dialogue when you fail to influence them to delay graduation feel unnecessarily harsh

This actually sounds like a bug, I'll check

(+3)

I hope in the final version, we will have some kind of Achievements page that tells us which endings we've gotten/need to get still, and give us a completion percent for other things like conversations between idols (assuming those are random every game.) Even better might be some kind of plot branch flowchart that shows which choices we haven't made at each chapter?

 Anyways, the game and writing is great so far! Very excited to get more endings! 

(+1)

If this is already in the game, ignore me!

Can we fill in the senbatsu election spots to 15? 

Can we have rooms to increase smart and funny?

(+1)

Theatres will increase Smart and Funny.

https://sadambober.itch.io/idol-manager/devlog/124303/update-beta-14-theater

I like the idea of being able to change the girls' outfits and hair. Maybe that can have something to do with the stylist?

Deleted 5 years ago

You can change a girl's looks, once you've hired a stylist, by clicking on the stylist icon (pair of scissors)at the bottom of the screen.

I must be blind! Thank you!

(+5)

I've been following Idol Manager since the Kickstarter campaign in March 2018 and finally played it around 3-4 months ago, and I love it. The new story update (although broken for me as I keep crashing whenever talking to my rival in chapter 4) adds a lot of content and replay value to the game. The direction the game is heading is great and I can't wait for its official release, but I think I want to add my feedback and suggestions to the mix:

- Staff should have their own personal traits like what the idols have. For example, a Dance Coach that has faster training time with idols over the age of 21, etc. It would also be nice to be able to choose an individual trait for my character.

- I think Staff should have their own satisfaction bar or ask for raises as your company gets more buzz. In my opinion it would be crazy for staff to be willing to work for a multi-million dollar company while earning way below the minimum wage.

- a PR manager would be a cool addition as a new type of staff that you can use to try to generate buzz, passively reduce the chances for scandals, or even create scandals to earn scandal points.

- A dedicated button in the bottom right to see list or graphs showing the growth of the company, income, fans, etc. and see the sales of songs or see songs that went gold, platinum, etc. 

- This might be out of the scope of the game, but I feel like streaming should have more depth to it than just being a simple policy. It would be cool that I have an idol become a dedicated streamer that promotes music, etc. Or even have the chance to make one of my idols become a virtual idol in the same vein as Hololive or Kizuna Ai.

(+1)

Can 'Reality' be a Genre for Media? Like a reality show? It can attract Hardcore, Female, Young Adult or Hardcore, Female , Teen? 

(+3)

1) View stats when members graduate (don't really know whether I want to push an idol's graduation back when I don't know their stats; also would love to see money made and other detailswhen idol actually graduates)

2) Easier way to see member’s wishes (auto-talk) (once I have a lot of idols, checking wishes individually becomes tedious)

3) See existing contracts when doing business proposals (see whether idol stamina cost per week/how many shows and contracts already has) 

4) Action cards become something if unused
5) Excess research points (after maxed out all choreo/genre, want to do something with it)
6) Election benefits (more than just fame, possibly company assigned, affect girl's mental stamina in long run)
7) Sort by number of fans
8) Show sister group with most fans
9) Randomly assign proposals
10) Dishes transfer with girls (if member changes group, dish stays with the other sister group)
11) Show election rank on profile
12) Easier to see idols on hiatus
13) show time in company
14) Number of members by sister group name
15) Stats on formation
16) Sort by overall stats
17) Don’t auto replace if on hiatus
18) Upgrade spa - more members, more stamina
19) Singles continue to sell

20) See which members are close to winning awards (hard to keep track of variety show/pretty queen)

21) show what audience sister group is targetting

22) more promotional stuff (release group videos)

23) easier training (training is pretty tedious right right now especially with a lot of girls, maybe be able to assign training by sister group)

"See existing contracts when doing business proposals (see whether idol stamina cost per week/how many shows and contracts already has) "

Click on an idols portrait to see this.

(2 edits) (+4)

i have played this game mostly in relaxed mode but i have a couple of things that would make me enjoy the game even more; 

- it would be nice if you can make a group even if you dont have 10 members, or at least after you unlocked the first sister group talk

- for the sake of telling girls apart (if youre like me and run companies with 10 groups) it would be nice if you could give girls member colours that show up as their name font colour and/or as a dot or line on their small picture

- and i know this one would be a huge thing to implement so i dont expect much of it, but it would be nice if you could swap outfits so you can make groups look cohesive without going through 50 auditions to find similar girls of good stats. another way is to allow the player to select which kind of girls to get in that audition (and save that until its changed again)

- it would be great help if you could hire someone to write lyrics

I agree with everything! However, for the last one, you can make Production/or Sales Managers write lyrics if they're max level. :D

(+4)

I want to recommend an option to release something like a mini album or a full album because that would be really interesting. But also, it could shoot you through the rankings! :)

(+4)

Actually. I might as well put down all of the suggestions and ideas I have.

  • An ability to do a promotional period. Where they can promote on shows and do performances.
  • An option to pick to release a mini-album that will take longer to make than a single. It could make you more money.
  • An option to pick to release a full-album.
  • An option to add a Music video alongside which can have a budget slider for how much you're willing to spend on the MV.
  • An ability to create your own genre that can grow in the industry.
  • An ability to buy a license to cover another artist's song that can earn you more fans from the fanbase.
  • A situation where a former idol will accuse another idol of bullying and harassment.
  • An ability to release songs in other languages (like how K-Pop have English and Japanese Releases to help reach out to a larger fanbase)

Big agree on albums and music videos.

Viewing posts 241 to 260 of 311 · Next page · Previous page · First page · Last page