Judge feedback

Judge feedback is anonymous and shown in a random order.

• Very charming game with a simple but engaging little game mechanic. I did get stuck a couple time as I picked up the potion in the submission area instead of placing one, but overall simple controls. The Alchemy theme was present and obvious, however I failed to see any trace of Shadows until I read the GDD to explain this.
• The art, music and sound effects were nicely done here. I found the way you had to play the game was simplistic and straightforward as well. Though, in regards to the themes being implemented, it that alchemy was more of the focal point here, while shadow only was brought up when it came to the description of the story being told. Unless there was something I missed during my playthrough, I didn't see anything tie back to how the character was an undercover agent, nor anything that spoke to a secret being uncovered. I did find the time I spent playing to be fun, especially when it got to the portion where the game specified for the player to "not cheat" (though I'm unsure if there was to be any indicators that the professor would catch you in the act if you did cheat). I'd like to see more of this, with the inclusion of whatever story you were describing in your GDD (again, unless I just missed something). Overall, keep up the good work
• Love it, there are some bug issues like clicking on the to do items and they get stuck to your mouse but the rest is amazing.