Maybe if the pits were bigger, so you had to first chase down a power up and then you would kill some monsters, and the process would repeat a few times before you progressed? The power ups could also have more distinct effects since they all look the same just different colors and shapes. Like maybe the square is a beam attack, and the circle is a bomb or something.
It's a bit hard to come up with ideas beyond that since I'm not sure how you want combat to feel, but hopefully my suggestion can give you something to think about if nothing else.