Loved the art style, especially the main character. Reading the main gamepage write up was very helpful as the information contained in the tab menu was essential for me to create the potions correctly. I also really liked the inclusion of atoning for your sins as it created a nice time pressure between making potions and then needing to go elsewhere periodically to break up the pattern.
Small feedback, but the image used for what I would call a garlic clove was a little hard to figure out what it was (the white one near the entrance portal). I was able to figure it out by knowing what the other 3d models corresponded to image-wise. Tweaking that one image could help make the recipe a little more intuitive.
Really nice work on creating this cute little game.