Story - Fun and unique! A thief cursed to be generous, like a Robin Hood if you had to twist his arm to get him to give to the poor. I dug it!
Mechanics - Pretty solid, if basic. Walk through rooms, collect loot, give it away to sewer beggars!
Theme - I liked the twist on the theme. Most of the games in the jam deal with the more positive aspects of generosity. I like the darker turn you took.
Audio/Visual - The visuals were pretty rad. The audio made me laugh - this guy is the best thief of all time, but he's stomping through people's houses with what sounds like a peg leg. Really funny. I really liked the loot acquiring animations though. Having the loot spring straight to your inventory was really satisfying and made me want to keep looting stuff!
Overall - I think you guys did a great job, and you used a custom engine! That's wild! Great work!