'Witchy Werewolf Wives' is an adorable fluffy romance between two ladies who find out that magic is real and they're stuck in the middle of it. It's a nice little story about the importance of open communication and listening and understanding your partner's needs. The art style is cute and adorable, with some really neat drastic shots, that make it feel like you're watching an animatic of a tv cartoon show. There's a few light-hearted humor bits mixed in with all the dramatic relationship stuff, so it doesn't feel like it's overly bogged down.
The set up for the story does feel a little bit random, with a lot of details being explained away, but for this kind of story, I don't think it detracts from it. I think the story attempts to explore more into themes of gender roles, gender expression, and even a bit of gender identity, when the werewolf girlfriend finds that their in the middle of figuring out whether they like the idea of being a big strong wolf, over their current body shape. But, they never really explore the part about not feeling right in their current form, even though there's mirroring with the main character, who gets transformed into a tiny wolf, so in a way the roles reverse in their dynamic. It's an exploration that doesn't fully explore. But, I think the overall message of 'accepting folks no matter how they present themselves as' is a simple and positive one.
The theme of 'light in the dark' gets shown in a few ways literally, like the fireworks at night or fireflies at night, but figuratively, I don't think that it's expressed in a way that feels integral to the story, since there's not really a 'dark' to contrast all the light-heartedness this story portrays. This story doesn't seem to take any big risks, as most revelations of magic and werewolves are quickly accepted, the ability to cast spells is given as an inherent ability, and the relationship drama is easily resolved. While the story does a give a good job of giving each character good characterization, it's very light on exploring their dynamic prior to this story. We meet the characters right at the mid-proposal, but we don't know all of the girlfriend's traits or insecurities leading up to it. We don't really see why the main character is in love with the girlfriend, just that she is. It doesn't detract from the story, but it does mean that it's very light and surface level.
Overall, it's a very cute read, with very cute visuals, and a very cute message, and if that's all it aimed to be, then it succeeded in that way.