My record was 4264!
I don't know if it was intentional, but after a while I lost the pumpkin icon. I thought I lost him, BUT I DIDN'T :D
I liked the music. Maybe it wasn't creepy, but it fit the fast paced gameplay nicely!
As for the graphics, I'll be honest- I don't love the AI graphics- I'd rather have pixel art style intro, like the gameplay. I think, having your own style, or working with someone else to make graphics for you always beats AI when it comes to the cool factor.
The gameplay was fun- I could see this as a mobile game. Adding the point counter was a cool touch too- I played a game multiple times to beat my score.
Over all- I see this was your firs jam game! First of all- congrats! Finishing a game is not easy, and you made it! My advice is double down on the cool fast paced gameplay, drop the AI, and see you on the next jam :)