Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Hello! I'm working on my first game (Japitown) and would love some feedback

A topic by AhhGames created Apr 26, 2026 Views: 2,549 Replies: 8
Viewing posts 1 to 5

Hi everyone!

I'm super excited (and a little bit nervous!) to share that I'm currently working on my very first game. It's a project called Japitown, and I'm developing it using Ren'Py.

At its core, the game is a Visual Novel, but I really wanted to step outside the standard formula and add more depth to the gameplay. To do that, I've been integrating life simulator elements and extra mechanics to make the world feel much more alive and give players more agency.

Since this is my first time taking on a project of this scale, I would absolutely love to get some feedback from this community. I want to make sure the project is heading in the right direction. Whether it's about the core gameplay loop, the UI, or how well the extra mechanics blend with the traditional visual novel style, any constructive criticism would be incredibly valuable to me.

https://ahhgames.itch.io/japitown

Thanks so much for taking the time to read this! If you have any general advice for a first-time indie dev, I'm all ears.

Cheers!

(2 edits) (+1)

Hi AhhGames,

I started the game, but unfortunately I got stuck at the airport, from there I could neither move nor get into the story (It was greyed out). Trying to move I accidentally took two screenshots - possibly S is not the be best choice for taking a screenshot when it is quite common to move with WASD. Anyway I'm making the best of the screenshot to show you that what appears to be my father has neither shadow nor reflection:

Anyway I finally managed to leave the airport and got into the story a little bit... I don't typically play visual novels so I can't tell whether I struggle through the story because of my limited Spanish or because the story is kind of slow paced... In the house I struggle to figure out the floor plan on the ground floor (I suspect the rooms appear to suit the story, not necessary where they geometrically would be). I like the lighting showing the time of the day. The visuals a OK, albeit partly unnaturally clean - fine in the kitchen but in the room of a teenager?

Hi Smurjo, thank you for your feedback! It's the first one I've received and it makes me really happy to get it.

You are right about that part—you stop just clicking and have to start interacting with the game. I think it's a good moment to explain the interaction mechanics to prevent other people from running into the same problem. I can definitely add the reflection; it's a detail I completely overlooked.

Regarding the second part, I also think I could add a short tutorial when you enter free mode to explain the features, and especially to show the hint menu where you can see how to progress with the quests (inside the phone, on the top right, there is an app where you can see what to do next).


 

The game does have an English version; I thought it was configured to start in English by default (you can find the language option inside the menu).



Regarding the room layout, it's just as you say: there is no realistic geometry to them. I simply made them functional so players could progress, but it is something I would like to redesign at some point.

Your point about the backgrounds being too clean is a great observation too; adding a bit of clutter will give them more life.

Thanks again for the feedback! I'll be working this week on putting together the mechanics tutorial, and I've taken note of the other observations you shared.

Best regards


P.S. Looking at the screenshots, I noticed that the quest name isn't translated. I'll fix that too!

(+1)

tell me if you need any help OR you can check my work here: Game tec - itch.io

Hi Game Tec, thanks for the offer. If I ever need anything at some point, I know I can count on you.

I see you have several games, I'll check them out over the next few days.

Best regards

(+2)

Hey AhhGamesI played the game, and really enjoyed it, thank you for sharing, 
I have recorded the playthrough where i speak out loud, and that should give you a few pointers on where I struggled with the game, and where I enjoyed the game. 


I am using AI to capture the feedback in text form (there is still some work to do on shaping this skill :) )

Here is the AI summary

Japitown playtest, my notes

Hi Alan, thanks for putting this out and for inviting feedback. I went in cold (didn't read the page first) and played a single ~13 minute session as a think-aloud test. Quick framing: I'm not the target audience for visual novels (I'm more of a French/Belgian comics reader and I don't usually play story-driven games), so take that into account, but I genuinely enjoyed the session more than I expected. The art and the opening scene with Papa carried it. Most of my friction was onboarding: figuring out what the game is, who these people are, and what I'm supposed to be doing in any given scene.

What I liked

  • The line art is the standout. Clean outlines, expressive, very alive. It's the first thing I noticed and the reason I wanted to keep going.
  • The Papa goodbye scene genuinely landed. I have kids around that age and the "smile and be happy when all you want is to hear them say I love you" beat is a real feeling. If you can hold that emotional precision through the rest of the writing, you have a real anchor.
  • Reading-wise it has the cadence of a graphic novel I'd want to keep going with. The framing of the panels and the dialogue rhythm work for me even as someone outside the usual VN audience.
  • The premise (returning home, rebuilding relationships with people whose dynamic has changed) is a strong hook on paper, even where the specifics didn't land for me in-session.

Where I got stuck

  • I never understood who the people in the house were. I figured out Papa, and I figured out I'd been away traveling. But once I arrived at Mónica's house I couldn't have told you the names or the relationships. I literally said out loud "I want to reconnect with everyone, but I don't know still who they are." For a relationship-driven game that's the foundational layer and it wasn't there for me. Onboarding/learning issue, not difficulty.
  • Nothing tells me what's clickable in a scene. In the very first Papa scene I sat there clicking around trying to find the interaction. The cursor turns into a hand on basically everything, so the cursor isn't signal. I get that the bed and backpack icons later are the navigation/action menu, but in dialogue scenes I couldn't always tell whether I needed to click the character, click somewhere on the panel, or wait.
  • The day/time system wasn't legible to me. I hit "too late for activities," the inventory was empty, the chat and relations panels closed when I clicked them, and I genuinely didn't know if I was stuck or just done for the day. I ended up clicking the bed because I'd run out of guesses. I now understand from your page that there are 4 time slots and characters move around the house autonomously, but none of that was visible to me as a player.
  • The "skip" button and several UI affordances are unlabeled. I couldn't tell what skip would skip, and several panels (chat, relations, map) gave no real explanation of what they were for. The "map content in development" placeholder is fine for early access, but the live ones could use a one-line description.
  • A few smaller bugs / polish notes from the session: the dialogue switched to Spanish at one point ("nada" type lines mid-sentence), at least one character kept smiling through dialogue where the emotional beat read as sad or angry, and the backpack contents seemed to change between a scene and the next in a way I couldn't trace.
  • I didn't pick up on the adult/romance framing during the session. I see now from the page that romance and 18+ content is core to what this is. From the playthrough alone, I read it as a relationship-drama story game. Not a complaint, more a flag that the in-game tone in the early scenes doesn't telegraph what kind of game I'm in. That might be intentional pacing and that's fine.

Suggestions

  • The tutorial that's already on your 0.1.5 roadmap would have solved most of my problems. I'd push it earlier if you can. Even a one-screen "here's the time system, here's your phone, here are the people you live with" would change the first session a lot.
  • Introduce the household by name and relationship on first contact. A single line per character ("Violet, Mónica's daughter, the quieter twin") the first time I see them would have grounded me. Right now I'm meeting people whose role I'm supposed to infer.
  • Make the time-of-day state explicit and tell me what to do when nothing is available. A small persistent indicator ("Evening, slot 3 of 4") plus a nudge when all options are exhausted ("nothing more to do tonight, sleep to continue") would have stopped me from clicking around lost.
  • For dialogue scenes, consider a subtle highlight on the thing the player needs to click to advance. The hand cursor isn't doing enough work on its own.
  • Audit the scenes for expression/dialogue mismatches. The art is strong enough that when a smile holds through a sad line, it really pulls me out. Worth a sweep.
  • On the AI disclosure: you've been transparent about it on the page, which I respect. The art holds up, the line work doesn't read as generic to me. Where it shows is mostly in small inconsistencies (a background detail here, a character expression that doesn't track the line there). Those are the things to keep hand-editing.

Overall

Genuine compliment first: there's something here. The art is good, the opening scene is emotionally real, and the premise has room to grow into the relationship system you're describing on the roadmap. For an Early Access 0.1, the foundation is more solid than I expected. The single highest-leverage thing you can do, in my view, is the onboarding layer: make the time system, the household, and the basic interactions legible in the first 5 minutes. The story bits are working. The interface is in their way.

Good luck with the development. Hope the feedback is useful.

(+1)

You've given me some great feedback!

I'm glad you liked it. The positive things you highlighted were exactly what I was aiming for, and I'm happy that it shows.

What you've said really helps me understand the areas I need to work on. I understand that a better introduction for the characters is very important since that's what the game revolves around. You're the first person to point this out to me, but I think it's one of the most important things to fix that I had completely overlooked.

Highlighting the interactable elements is also important and something that came up in several other pieces of feedback, which is why I want to introduce a tutorial and add more visual cues.

I will also cover the system for the days and the characters in the tutorial, explaining all the game mechanics.

The labels are important too. I need to figure out how to add them for some of the engine's built-in functions, but I'm adding it to my list of pending fixes.

The issues with the text are something I'm currently reviewing. I learned the hard way how the translation system works in the engine; I changed several texts in Spanish (the original language) and those changes end up breaking the translated text. I'm fixing them as I find them.

I'm going to start with the tutorial as the first new addition to the game. I think understanding the basics is a fundamental step, along with properly introducing the characters.

In addition to the tutorial, I have some changes planned for the routes so that the game itself guides you through what you can do, helping you understand what your options are during the downtime outside of quests.

I'm going to work more on the visual indicators for the player so the gameplay loop and interactables are easier to understand.

I have several tweaks to make that I've been noting down regarding character expressions, as well as expressions I feel are missing in certain situations.

Regarding the AI, I spent a lot of time dialing in the game's art style so it wouldn't feel generic and would have its own identity, while also staying consistent. I'm glad to know it comes across that way! I don't use AI for the script or the expressions, so those mistakes are entirely on me.

I'm going to get to work on your suggestions. Once again, thank you so much for the feedback; it is extremely thorough and of excellent quality.

(+2)

The game has all the mechanics needed for this kind of game, but the movement still needs some work because it feels… off.

The strongest point for me is the art and the number of sprites the characters have, as well as how distinct they are from each other. Some visual novels have the issue that you don’t really notice changes in the characters’ expressions, but here you can appreciate them even while your eyes are focused on the text below.

The game looks very promising. I’ll add it to my collection and keep following its development.

Promising

Thanks a lot for taking the time to leave this feedback!

You're totally right about the movement; it's on my to-do list to improve. I'm still trying to find the best way to fix it so that it feels dynamic but stays simple to handle.

It makes me really happy that you pointed out the art and sprites as a strong point. That was something I really wanted to stand out right from the start, and it’s definitely what took me the most hard work to pull off!

I hope you stick around and keep following the project because it's going to keep evolving constantly. Thanks for the support!