Overall: A solid visual foundation with a functional 3D world, but the game balance needs work and a potential softlock is a critical issue to resolve.

What Worked Well:

• Title Screen: Good to see hover states on the menu buttons.
• Visuals: The 3D world works well. The plane baseline, firing sprite, and enemy plane all look good.

Areas for Improvement:

• Hitting the Enemy: It was very tough to land a hit. The  hit detection, hitbox size, and projectile firing needs tuning.
• Running Out of Ammo: I ran out of ammo without finishing the enemy. If there's no way to recover from that, the game is softlocked. That needs to be addressed either with ammo pickups, a reload mechanic, or some way to reset the encounter.

It's a little difficult to understand, but it's a good attempt. You can rate my game. Starbound Paradis