This was a great take on the theme! Very frantic and fun. I love how simple the core mechanic is, and yet how tense the gameplay gets. I also love the variety, in that sometimes the spin helps you and everything feels great, and other times you have to really fight the spin. Are those random, or are you intentionally mixing them up so that sometimes the spin helps and sometimes it hurts?
The graphics and sound design are also top-notch, making for a really polished experience. The frosting itself has a nice look to it (and I love the glossy look of everything). My boss yelling at me for a particularly-bad cake is also a nice touch :)
I like games like this that just take a simple, fun idea and execute it well without trying to pile a bunch of extra stuff on top of it. Amazing job!