I had fun with this. It took me many, many tries to get over the water :( but then from there things were smooth. But yeah it does feel like slow and steady wins. I think you did a good job here; every time I fell over it made me want to immediately try again instead of making me want to give up. I like the style of the graphics (I got a kick out of the sign that the cool cowboy labeled himself with). Sound effects were good, though I might have liked some music to go along with it.
All-in-all, a solid jam entry. Very fun! Nice work.