1265 points. Feels like a good score :)
Gameplay: I enjoyed the game enough to play it a few times. If it had an online leaderboard I'd probably play it even more to get to the top. Simple to grasp, but takes a minute to master :)
Graphics + Audio: Nice, oldschool, readable. Competent pixel art, but I guess it would be cool if there was some more style to make it more "yours".
Theme: More "star" than "gazing". I get how it relates to the theme.
Over all- really enjoyable, fast paced gameplay, where you need some skill and a bit of luck is what I want from an arcade game. Keep up the good work!