I <3 endings that leave you unfulfilled
It's interesting how this unfolds from a melancholic but kind of comforting story at first into gradually something where more and more is wrong... The charming sprite art helps to lull one into that impression as well huhu.
I appreciate that Stella's mental illness is of course not itself the thing that makes it Toxic but like the end of a thread to pull on that makes the rest unravel. There is a real commitment to maintaining her agency there despite her own struggles. The things she participates in at her job despite feeling guilty for it, and how even at the end her loneliness is noted to be self-imposed... And yet there is something still so "harsh" about the outcome in a fascinating way, a sense of "unfairness". The very universe itself responds to her behaviour (the scene where the "news spreads fast" was quite striking o_o) and I can't help but feel sorry for her as someone in a vulnerable position at the intersection of many marginalisations herself.
Like, she didn't mean to violate Alcyone in that way but that doesn't mean it didn't happen, and that the foundation for their romantic relationship wasn't such a festering void as a result.
There's something quite real as well about how she kept on doubting their love as something that might not count as real, how hurtful that was to Alcy, even if she was just doing so out of her own self-loathing and self-denial. Regardless of the fantastical lore about stellar bonds it feels quite true to life re: emotionally avoidant types indeed. But she did make her own choices through both actions and inaction here.
I guess that bittersweetness is what makes it good toxic yuri. Well done
I don't want to sell short how eerily the visuals for her moments of unreality were done either. Truly a gift for disconcerting imagery on display.
(Also hmm I noticed that throughout that scene where she first arrives at work Stella's sprite is speaking with Alcyone's name tag. If that is intentional it does raise many questions. My first thought was that sleeping with her somehow caused Alcyone's essence to be absorbed into her/possessing her a bit in a kind of Plural reading but also she Is a person who exists outside of her body so moreso mixing metaphors there. 🤔 I mean every time Before we see either of them in the present day, they are represented by cardboard cutouts who don't look like either of their appearances currently... Part of that may be down to transition but quite interesting either way.)