yeah so that's a bug so you might want to wait for the next patch
Viewing post in Untitled UNDERTALE Vore Game comments
I finally got the western frog's green star! Just like in Super Mario Galaxy! I was admittedly kind of dumb and didn't get the references for a long while. Though a strange bug occurred that granted me access to Hard Mode upon getting that green star despite the run away bug. Not sure what happened or why, but just thought you should know.