Me and my friends have done a couple of game jams now and I think a big thing that helped us out is making a base-line repository of generic classes/blueprints to reuse across game jams - stuff like dialogue/quests/inventory base classes that can be ported to any new game we try to make and it really lets us focus on the theme and actual implementation of the kind of game we want to make.
Here's a game me and my buddies made if you want to check it out: /jam/brackeys-16/rate/494757
A small pitch:
"The end of the world is here, but no one seems to trust that you're sane. Convince the town of Wyoming that you've got your head straight. Lead these sheep to the truth, because nobody can be trusted to do so, but you..."