THE DESLIA ASTEROID V1.0 by Adalil
Reviewed by: C'est Moi, Le Justonky
Alright, let’s do this Steam Review Style, with a rubric I conjured up out of thin air based on the things I care about.
The file name says "Astronaut Mission Jam", you should be able to change the file name in your project page, unless I am getting an older version locked to when I was assigned the PDF in the queue? Not sure.
Ideas/Plot holes
Can't say I noticed any, but what if a PC sacrificed themselves to give more space to the scientists in lieu of fixing the ship? It's not a binary that the Scientists (however many there are) and the PCs unable to be mixed together. Maybe a team of scientists and PCs do one and another hybrid team do another, and only some can survive. Add traitor mechanics for spiciness.
Also, screw the corpos. All my homies hate the corpos. Continue.
The rest of these could be considered unsolicited. I admit I started writing these before taking a closer look at your request to focus on idea and plot. Oops. I apologize in advance:
Rules Clarity
It’s Systems Agnostic, so we can pretty much ignore this one. That said, the lore details are highlighted, and there’s ease of use in integrating this into existing game. I like the T-minus use of the timeframe, helps contextualize the temporal space the adventure takes place in. Which will be helpful for any GMs.
Textuality (Prose)
It does the job! I like the little fourth wall break where you ask if the PCs are happy being murderers. Rules text should be like that, it should have a voice. This ain’t MtG.
Gameplay
N/A (what system do I even have that can run this? 40k Dark Heresy? That would be a nice adaptation)
Aesthetics
The green swirly ASCII art reminds me of Austin Powers for some reason, and so I naturally imagined the entire game as outlined as a 60’s retro sci-fi with hippies in space. Yeah. But since it’s systems agnostic, it can be for anything really. Thematically speaking, this game could have been a hard sci-fi thriller about capitalist greed coming soon to theatres.
Layout
A bit tight, but you wanted to fit everything in a single A4 sheet of paper (or as we canucks say, Letter Size), so mission accomplished. I would suggest maybe adding 0.5 point (or thinner) vector lines between the columns or sections to help separate things, especially where the T-minus time frame goes into the second page, it helps if there are break lines indicating it’s latter parts is part of a prior a paragraph and is distinct from Deslia Asteroid details.
Typography
You have a hierarchy of information that is logical. However, running out of space for the Asteroid details section caused some confusion with what should be distinct sections all getting jumbled up. If you ever expand this into a proper zine (or just give it more pages), the extra breathing rule could let you do interesting thing, and you could give your ASCII art proper breathing room here, with nothing on top. Of course, no need to just redo the same game, you can always up-cycle this idea into a bigger idea. Stealing from yourself is the secret technique of all creatives.
PS: You made yours in a single day too? Heck yeah! Nothing like doing it last minute. Gets the creative juices flowing.