No, Eirik "missed his moment" with that choice. He chose to keep things detached and talk about the case at the point when Grey was at her most vulnerable. Was that unexpected for you?
a pinch yeah, since most dating sim rpg's punish choosing choices like that during a serious interaction and i didnt wanna risk potentially softlocking after an entire day of gameplay. enjoyed the game though, one of the few i had to actually consider the outcome of my actions since no rollback. would like if you added a reconcile option or dropped a walkthrough
edit: grey also didnt give off the vibe she was that kinda girl, considering her experience with other suitors just wanting to get in her pants so you could see why i chose the other option