It really isn't awful. It was a complete game. Even if the dialogue was fairly simple, it had it's moments, especially at the beginning.
Also the Lumberjacks sprite was something xD
Few things that would have been nice:
1. full screen option on web
2. The text skipping regardles on which part of the screen you click
3. placeholder text left when you accusse someone before finding all the evidance. "this is a test"
4. Some small ending screen / try again button
Good job!
