Play manual
Off-Nominal Downlink's itch.io pageResults
| Criteria | Rank | Score* | Raw Score |
| How stylish is this mission, visually? | #3 | 3.667 | 3.667 |
| How appropriate/desirable is this as an astronaut mission? | #7 | 3.667 | 3.667 |
| Overall | #9 | 3.500 | 3.500 |
| How well are design principles used to create a fun mission? | #10 | 3.500 | 3.500 |
| How legibile and easy-to-understand is this mission? | #10 | 3.167 | 3.167 |
Ranked from 6 ratings. Score is adjusted from raw score by the median number of ratings per game in the jam.
Which astronaut RPG/setting is this for?
System Agnostic
Which hard mode challenges did you do?
No images or diagrams
only text (ASCII art is allowed).
Write your mission for 1 player and no GM.
Optional theme Last-chance rescue.
What do you want comments/critiques to focus on?
This is a bit of a weird concept, what could make it work? I'm not sure the current version pulls of the idea of the "talking solo into the void feeling like a fun game", but that's what I'm shooting for. What are the snags, does this demonstrate the idea properly? What would it take to get you play this yourself?
How harsh do you want people to critque your submission?
Normal amount
Leave a comment
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.


Comments
I love this! The layout is minimalist and super atmospheric and the game itself has tension baked in. Like others have said, there’s a replayability discussion to be had and further to that, some interesting possible expansion. Really, really cool work
This is a really clever concept that I've never seen before. I really liked it! I especially liked the parts that were damaged. It makes the document feel a lot more real.
My only complaint is that I feel like I can only play it once. I don't think the challenge is quite the same if I already know what's in the document.
Also since I'd never played a game in this style before, I didn't really grok how it was supposed to be run until I read the scoring section. This meant I accidentally spoiled it for myself without realizing it! I'm not as good at following directions as your distressed astronaut hopefully is.
The possibility to do a new clever concept was very much my design driver for this: Trying out if this could be done as a concept. I really like game jams for exploring new ideas, making innovations, even if they end up lacking -- especially the usability in this ended up poor, it would have required more guidance to the player. But alas, with the deadline drawing near, it was always more fun to add more play content over more explanation.
In some way I even personally like the experience being so fleeting: You do it once, and then you've experienced it. But I would like to add stuff in, to have a couple more "puzzles" there. I think there this version is also a bit lacking, having a bit more challenges, with a "thing" to get would make it a more complete thing.
I really loved this: great concept; great execution.
It felt very playable and playful, while putting the player in quite an intense and immersed headspace.
The visual design was perfectly thematic (although it might be nice to print; coffee-ring and rescan for authenticity).
It (necessarily) lacks replayability, but I can't fault it for that.
I'm so happy you got it!
The playful is a good way to put it, it is in some sense quite "free form play". A small, fun thing you can do.
The print+rescan is a great idea, producing the small imperfections that are really hard to fake. That's going in the next version. Wonder if I could find a really bad scanner somewhere :P
this made me think of Apollo 13 where they tried to understand what went wrong while communicating with the crew and Jack Swiger stressing about his taxes.
i don't play solo or duo games often but i had trouble with this one as some stuff isn't very clear to me.
the checklist are mostly what I don't understand, am I just supposed to say the things written down out loud ? when do I know to go to the next line ? same for the circuit check I really have no idea how to proceed with this one either.
I think it would need more guidance for each section and have a way to know when the correct answer is found.
First things first - I really like the concept. I have been thinking myself about how to make these sorts of 'communication games' (what I like to call this sort of game, even if it's solo) - I will detail those thoughts after my thoughts on the mission.
I really like the format and design of a technical manual, as it really fits with the subject matter. But I found the text a little too small too read, especially given the relatively large size of the paper. Seems like possibly too much white space in places.
In terms of actual gameplay, it's a bit unclear what the player needs to do. I think it could use some more explicit instructions on how to play before throwing the player in there.
Personally, in this sort of game I'd want some sort of feedback from the astronaut as to how things are going. I know the central conceit of this specific mission is that the comms are down, but potentially they might have some sort of alternate communications, even if that's morse code, or similar. Potentially, you could procedurally generate the astronaut's responses with tables when solo playing.
It's asking a bit more, but another thing I'd personally like is a (separate?) manual on communication protocols, simply for immersion.
My thoughts on communication games:
For context, I have played Keep Talking And Nobody Explodes, but not Apollo 47.
I think the strengths of communication games generally rely on the puzzles - complicated scenarios that rely on the player's ability to communicate effectively and efficiently within a time limit. They have to be designed in such a way that they are complicated and specific, but not too hard to decipher. (I think the two that you do have work well on that front.)
To translate it to a solo game requires a bit of a change I think, because you don't have the same dynamic between two (or more) people having to communicate, so you've removed half of the game.
I think there's definitely multiple ways to do solo communication games:
If you (or anyone else reading this) have any further thoughts I would be very interested in talking it though more, since it's quite the interesting design challenge.
Yeah let's return to this discussion on the server, this is an interesting design challenge. How to make a communication game single-player, delightful paradoxality there.
I think there's an inherent double challenge here, like you say, the game really lives or dies on the quality of its puzzles -- the ones here are not great puzzles. ((and puzzle in the wide sense)) But then the "communication game" also needs to work. So double challenge, making good puzzles, that also work well for the spoken format, and here solo. Whereas good puzzles themselves are already hard to design.
Being honest, I miss instructions on how to actually play this. I’m playing solo as mission control — should I be journaling my side of the conversation, or literally speaking out loud to an empty room? The doc says “no gamemaster” and that mission control specialists are the only players, so it’s not fully clear who or what is on the other end even conceptually, let alone what I’m supposed to do to “keep talking” to them. A line early on spelling out the expected physical action (speak aloud, write it down, etc.) would remove a lot of hesitation before starting the clock.
The scoring table at the end has the same problem — I don’t know how I’m supposed to use it for solo game. Things like “brought up personal details” or “connected with the astronaut personally” imply I should be tracking that as I go, but there’s no prompt during the checklist steps reminding me to do it, and no guidance on whether I’m self-scoring live or reconstructing it from memory afterward.
What would get me to actually play it: a clear statement of what solo play looks like in practice, a note on when/how to use the scoring table, and either simplified checklists or a mechanic that rewards improvising through a stumble, so the human/emotional side has real support at the table, not just intent in the framing text.
I was meaning to answer a lot sooner, but thought I still should despite this being delayed! But a month is not that bad.
But with hindsight, you're absolutely correct to be puzzled. I think this is a case of me getting the design on the paper, but then fumbling on writing instructions since "I know what's supposed to happen." And this is a weird little thing, so picking it up is hard.
The feedback is great and actionable -- what I'm learning is that especially solo games should have clear examples of play, and more guidance for the player. Especially if they're a bit weird.
I can clarify it now, the intent is for the player to literally speak alound in an empty room. The dream is that the human stress of talking alone would help create a tense situation. Like it feels weird, and to use that weirdness.
But thanks for the feedback! I'll likely work this into a improved version down the line with this taken into account. Of the feedback I got, I think yours had the clearest, most directly applicable. I can definitely see the problem, and writing more clarification should help solve this! Let's see when I get around to update this :)