Thank you so much for taking the time to make an hour long video of my entry, thats simply amazing value for me as a creator! Your scoring is well founded and I appreciate all of it, and thank you for your honesty, this is exactly the kind of input I needed now to take the next steps of improving the game further!
Size of the level is a huge one that had not occurred to me yet, but it makes absolute sense. You default to auto-exploring after a while because its so big per level, and it killed the flow for you I think, just backtracking to the shrine was difficult.
And clearly I missed on the difficulty, its too hard, specially for a jam game, as its standing in the way for you to experience everything the game has to offer. I did tune difficulty a lot (and you had a better experience in the new version than in the jam version), but it was still a bit too hard.
I was like "YES!" when you survived the deep dwarves and the troll on the first try, then "D'OH!" when you walked straight into the poison cloud 😆
Some things you didn't get to see:
- river currents dragging you down waterfalls, forcing level changes.
- pushing monsters into chasms
- frost freezing water tiles
- procedural puzzle rooms with zelda like solutions, like shoot a special tile through a gate to open the gate, light braziers, electricute machines by zapping water that connects them, pull levers, rolling boulders and more
- boss battles with dark souls like mechanics and ai
- Lunging weapons
- And more
I never saw someone play at that resolution, so sorry for the log not wrapping to the next line or hud elements overlapping. At least the text size made it easy to read watching your video on mobile!
Finally, you're absolutely right on the aesthetics working against readability a bit, specially in lairs/vaults/treasure rooms you saw. I will fix those.
Again this was extremely valuable to watch, and I'm yet again thankful for you putting in the time to cover it so thoroughly!