Hello, LateNightGamer! Here I go with my review for your entry.
[Note: Please don't take my criticism too hard, as I am trying to be as constructive as possible, and nothing is further from my intentions as to sound harsh or unrespectful with your work. I want for all of us to improve through these jams and I am learning myself to give a focused and attentive listen and thoroughly and sincerely comment other's entries as much as I would like mine to be reviewed.]
I listened to the Bandcamp version of your entry with closed-back headphones.
Track by track review:
1. Welcome
Great ominous vibes. The birds sound a bit mechanical, and the repeating background tinkling gets a tad annoying at the end. Maybe could get tamed a bit volume-wise and put more in the background.
2. Night Walk
The background and general instrumentation being the same than the first track is deterimental to the listening experience. It sounds like a different take of the first track, instead of a new one. Around the 0:50, really interesting things start to happen, with a kind of "crying baby" sound, and a hint of a melody. However, the repetition makes it lose force after a few seconds. At 1:40 there's a really cool transition to sci-fi territory. I still feel the artificial nature of some samples used, as they need more work to change their texture and pitch to feel less repetitive and more organic, but maybe this was intented, as it does create a sense of uneasiness. Feeling some kind of "evil laughter" of the landscape overall here. At the end of the track there seems to be an unintentional trailing silence for several seconds.
3. Meditation
Interesting textures and sound design. Loving the dripping sounds starting around the one minute mark and how it blends with the low-end. Very eerie and "haunted" feeling with the "oohs". Around the 2 minute mark it starts to feel a bit repetitive and asking for a change. That change arrives at 2:30 with the piano, which is really cool and works great. The ending playing note seems to be a bit rushed, not sure if that's intended.
General impressions:
Overall, your album gave me very dark and creepy feelings, like being in a haunted environment where strange things are about to happen. I think your tracks would work great in a horror setting and I felt the connection to the "lake" theme was strong.
Ratings by category:
Execution: 3/5
I found your work was good execution-wise (playing and mixing), but some perceived errors make me refrain from giving it 4 stars. I feel it would need some mixing improvements, work at making the samples more interesting and diverse and polishing some other minor issues, as mentioned in the review for each track.
Vibe: 3/5
The atmosphere was interesting overall, but I felt that because of the repetitive nature of some elements, I was not so immersed as I could have been.
Composition: 3/5
As in the execution category, here I found that there's room for improvement and more nuance and variance is needed to make the tracks shine. While the background soundscape works great, the added SFX and melodic elements feel they need more development.
Listenability: 3/5
I listened to it one time and I enjoyed it, but did not feel like listening to it a second time.
Correlation to Theme: 4/5
I think the general vibes you achieved conveyed perfectly the sense of both the lake and its secret and mysterious nature. It might lack some oriental elements to make it fully fit with the image and prompt, but the connection is still strong.
________________________________________
And just FYI, for this jam I am starting to use a rating rubric/template in order to rate more consistently and make my feedback more insightful for the person I am rating. It is available here in case you wanted to check it out: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1LEz4pyyHR7iQ75W2IFjA22odaeDNmdm-/view?usp=shari...