Very professional looking game, lots of beautiful art and awesome music! Animations!!! What a sight for sore eyes. Voice acting, too, is such a hard thing to pull off but you guys did it perfectly. And the menus are absolutely gorgeous! Again, very professional. Clearly, this game was made by pros!
The actual brewing minigame could use some polish, it's a little basic and I'm pretty sure only gives unique dialogue on the first brew. This made me restart a couple times to see what the characters will say about a potion. In my opinion, having these lines as separate scenes that play whenever you see a new potion would've been better than having them as part of a predetermined order of scenes for the first 3 brews. There's little reason to not have them play after the first 3 brews anyway. I think this decision was made because of time constraints, and I know it's not a big deal or anything, but I would've loved it if you guys returned later to this game and polished this up!
Writing is funny, the characters are adorable, and the story is short and sweet. I like the message quite a lot, it's a good twist on the stereotype and subverts your expectations of wanting to win in a good way.
Overall, you guys killed it with this one! It's a great game!!!