This was the funniest one I've seen yet, hands down. The writing was absolutely beautiful, and so were the personalities. It's very clear a lot of love and work went into this game. I really wasn't sure what I'd be getting when I downloaded this, but I'm very glad I got to this today. I only played through once (and saw HawkZombie's playthrough last night), and I'll admit that my sacrifice was Emily. I absolutely refuse to sacrifice Brad.
With that being said, my main concern is with doing multiple playthroughs. I'm not sure how many conversations there are, or if ANY of the choices are correct in the end, but my concern is with people getting the same conversations through multiple playthroughs simply by choosing the same combination of characters without realizing they've seen it already. Since this is easily a thirty-minute to an hour-long game, I was startled to find that there wasn't a save option at any point. I think that either there should be an option to save, OR (if it's possible) a way that the game can keep track of which conversations have already been seen. I know that DURING a playthrough, the game does this so conversations aren't repeated. Is there a way to make that span over multiple runs? That way if a player WANTS to see everything, they could? I'm probably going to play this again since it was hilarious, and I would like to see each ending at some point. I'm just not sure how much the hilarity will shine if I forget which conversations I've seen and somehow manage to select it a few times in a row.
That, however, is the only criticism I have. This was amazingly well-done, especially for a game jam entry. Your team should be exceedingly proud of what they accomplished here.
