I really liked this! There's definitely a few places I think there needed to be a little more explanation/backstory, but overall I enjoyed how crazy the first 1/2 was and how fun the second 1/2 was to go back over with. I was honestly a little worried how similar this was to Type Help when I first started playing, but as I got further into the story, and then the second half, I forgot all about that worry! I love how unique the story is, and all of the different list items you can uncover.
likes and dislikes
Things I liked:
- A lot of people apparently didn't like the wordle? I thought it was a fun mini-puzzle and great change of pace, but I can understand that it might be frustrating if you play it as regular wordle (you don't need to type real words!)
- I looooved how fast the story was. It was maybe a little hard to take seriously but it didn't take away from the puzzle aspect imo, and it was just hilarious to find a new feed and woops! dissolved by aliens!
- I also liked going back over everything in the second half of the game, and eventually discovering why everyone was acting so weird & why everything went wrong. I think it's super cool to look over everything in a new light.
- I liked having multiple types of files to discover.
- I liked the implications of the characters having lives beyond the story and the Necromancer continuing on to other planets. I also liked that we never quite figure out some of the mysteries (like what the rift really is, or how the Necromancer got here in the first place)
- In the first half of the game, when we find Lenny dead, I was SO baffled. I literally labelled the feed "wtf happened to lenny." I was elated to discover that "what happened to lenny" was one of the questions posed in the conclusion email.
Things I didn't like:
- Carl (ew) (literally anyone else deserved that blunt)
- I got super stuck a couple times, namely with Barry's last name, despite having the right feed already. Perhaps I could have noted that down earlier, but I was kind of startled by having only one location to find that compared to how difficult I found the others to get.
- I'm usually a completionist in games, but I couldn't do this one. The two things that stopped me were not being able to tell when I had all of the people for a timestamp, and not knowing which 99 feeds counted as actual files. Since there wasn't a super clear way of knowing when someone's body stopped counting as a person, I was never really sure if I had completed a person's feeds (I found out way later in the game that Zack has one more scene without Alex). I also found it super discouraging that you can get an "empty room" feed for literally every* empty room & time, but that only some of them counted. Since there's no clear way of knowing what's important (just guessing), I assumed I would have to go through literally every room and timestamp to find all of the files.
- While I overall enjoyed the story, I do think there are a few blank spots that left me wanting. I don't mind some ambiguity, but I got really confused on what Jackie was actually doing (trying to contain the evil residue or something?), what Michael's plan was (where was he taking all that stuff, and was he actually in psychosis or was that Necromancer?), and what on earth happened to Lenny (the Investigator says Necromancer looks like Lenny, but that's before Necromancer eats(?) Lenny, and Lenny becomes a separate shadow person, so why would it already look like that?) (that last one is definitely a nitpick.) None of these make me not like the game, but I do still wish we had a little more clarity.
- This last one is just something I missed in the endgame that I wish was a little more hinted at: I completely missed the final 17- feed, even though I knew there was something there. I knew there should have been a scene at 17, and I knew there was probably some sort of puzzle tied to the power distributor, but for the life of me I could not figure out the connection. I actually did the correct thing at first, but that didn't do anything that I saw, so I switched the power elsewhere. I wish there was any more hints that the relay was connected to the camera's range. I just assumed we couldn't see into that location because of the temporal anomaly stuff. This is something that might just be my own mistake, but I still wish it were clearer.
Hope this doesn't come across as too whiny lol. I really did enjoy the game, and hope to maybe see more like it (even just text-based, I love text-based games!). Definitely a great way to spend my day.