I'm surprised you find 5 characters too many, especially when most IFs average 4-5 ROs. Each character plays a vital role in the story itself, so I personally feel like they all deserve to be there in some shape or form.
Furthermore, having a romance lock after 650,000+ words feels fairly reasonable to me... But I'm curious to hear where you'd place the romance lock. This is meant to be a trilogy, where Book 1 allows you to explore your romance options, Book 2 develops the relationship and Book 3 focuses on solidifying the relationship even further. After 12 chapters, I’d expect most players to know which character(s) they want to pursue (if any).
Regardless, I appreciate that you gave the story a chance and I’m glad that you liked it, however, a lot of the "flaws" you pointed out are subjective. While you are allowed to feel all of the above, I am happy with the game as is and hope you can enjoy it in this state too. I will also add that I am very much a character-driven writer, so that’s why a lot of chapters feel slow; I prefer to focus on the development of the cast over the action. But thank you for reading <3