I believe the edge of the screen works for me, but I think around the player might work for others. Hopefully other users will weigh in with their opinions so you can get a general idea on what people prefer.
Ya know what, why not both? While developing this, I won't assume anyone one preference suits all with settings like this. So, I can add an option to make the guiding arrow surround player or outline the edge of the screen and it can just be switched.
I've been doing almost all setting in a way that allows customization, with my preference as the default.
Just like all of these: