The black background on that list is normal, that's how all replay menus look right now.
Juno's and Robin's replays play fine on my end, so can you tell me:
- What happens when you tap one? Black screen, error, or back to the list?
- Do other girls' replays work?
If you can send me your save file too, that would help a lot. On PC it's in the game folder under game/saves. Just DM it to me or you can mail it to me as well : wargnema@gmail.com