You’re right that Discord shouldn’t be the only place a project lives. But that’s not what this is. PadManiacs is small, the server is empty, and itch.io stays as the public record no matter what happens here.
The reason for the Discord is practical: the next features (leaderboards, online multiplayer, SSC and DWI support) are hard to build alone. I need fast back-and-forth, not comment threads that take months to appear. Discord is where that conversation can happen. itch.io can’t do that.
So if the server dies tomorrow, nothing important is lost. But if it works, it’s where the game actually gets built with you.