Played STAY three times, twice on purpose with different rooms, once just to see the second ending.
The beat that got me: visitor four asks for the light off one turn after the lamp was the only thing that saved visitor two. The thing you set down to keep one person is the reason the next one leaves. You never explain that, you just let it happen, and it lands. Best single move in the piece.
What I found underneath it. The ceiling is 4, not 5, and there's only one road there: chair, lamp, rug, in that order. A placement is permanent and you get one per visit, so lamp-for-two and no-lamp-for-four cannot both be true. I tried lamp first and scored 3. So the "choice" is one correct sequence, and your ending line ("one always walks") admits it. Honest, but it also means the second play is a recitation. Somebody who likes this will play twice, so the second time needs to say something new.
Three things that cost you almost nothing:
1. Say it before they place. One line over the tray: what you set down stays. Right now permanence is learned by losing.
2. Let the skip be visible. Pressing GO with an empty tray is legal but reads as a glitch. Make the button say "let them go" when nothing is placed, and a loophole becomes a decision.
3. Give the room a memory. Visitors fade, objects sit there unchanged. After the fourth one, a scuff on the floor or a cold patch under the window would tell me the room felt them.
The quiet parts are right. Cream paper everywhere, one warm amber rectangle in a dark frame, serif type, and the visitor sliding in from off-frame is the nicest motion in it. The still frame before you press GO does more work than any animation could.
Small copy note: "that's a room" in the four-stayed ending is the strongest line in the game. Put that voice in the header too.