This game is incredible. I knew Ellis was a bit of a red flag in the previous acts but little did i know. Act 3 is definitely my favorite act now. There’s so many different branches and choices to go through and they’re all so well-done! Thank you Memo, for creating a masterpiece!
Spoilers ahead! Be warned!
I’m ashamed to say… I got the “Good Pet” ending first try. I mean, he cooks for us? He made us cucumber sandwiches?? Omg how sweet his previous transgressions is totally forgiven! :3 /sarcastic (kinda)
I can be his cucumber sandwich if he wants… (get it? because.. of my name..? haha..ha..)
I wonder how MC will get out of it in the next act. Specifically how Benji is in the cellar with us at Ellis place? This is just a theory, but I do believe Benji’s dead, because of the dream MC had with the bloody bathroom, but also because MC drank from the water bowl just before she noticed him for the first time. It seems strange that it took so long for MC to notice him. Sooo, maybe some of the tonic that Ellis great-great-grandmother created got mixed in the water bowl? The tonic in which you see dead people? AAA I can’t wait to find out more!
I feel so sorry for the “pets” that came before. But man, Ellis do be kinda adorable, in his own quirky little serial-killer way…. I CAN FIX HIM, RIGHT? Or maybe make him worse? /sarcastic again (kinda)
Benji is also such a complicated man as well. He wants MC to be his MC, and the instant they do something different, he cracks. When you do what he wants, he showers you with that reliable affection he’s so well at maintaining/manipulating. But when you don’t.. Well, yeah…
The scene where you buy the ibuprofen for the “Emotionally Compromised” ending is so interesting to me. He doesn’t really mind MC having these difficulties and thoughts, what bothers him is that she does it without him. Without asking him for help. He even said himself that sometimes he drives MC to it (indirectly or directly) because he wants them to rely only on him. Man needs therapy, what a shame he hates it. I find it quite fascinating though.
I’m very invested in knowing what Benji is going to do at the cabin in the woods. Like how long do he expect them to be there? In one of the endings it’s reported people know they’re missing after a while, so they can’t be there forever, right? Eventually, they will have to leave the cabin, and how is that going to affect them both? I’m so excited for next update..
I’m so happy Act 3 is your favorite! This one took the longest, and I was looking forward to finally getting to explore more of the horror themes. I probably dug myself into a hole with all the various branches, but I love when games hide little surprises that you don’t even see until a second playthrough.
Hahaha, I hope you named yourself Sandwich in the game, that would be awesome. Also, you’re very kind for appreciating Ellis's cooking, as I can’t imagine those sandwiches tasted very good lol.
Ok so I’m not going to confirm or deny anything, but just know that your attention to detail is very astute, as is your ability to connect all of them together. If I were playing a murder mystery game, I'd want you on my team! Rest assured, more will be revealed in the next act(s)...not sure how many more there will be.
I wanted both of them to have a “light” side to offset their dark side, but also to remind us that they're still human, which I think makes them scarier. Also, your thoughts on Benji are correct. He is a very complicated, desperate person. I do believe he genuinely cares for the player, but might be hiding behind the act of care to avoid facing a lot of truths about himself.
There will most likely be a scenery change next act, but not necessarily someplace brand new. I’m still kinda working that out. As you can see, many of the endings are still kinda open-ended. I like leaving a little room for people to use their own imaginations and tell their own stories.
Anyways, thank you SO much for playing again and for your amazing theories! Reading ppl’s analyses has been my favorite part of this experience!