Play game
Moonlight Fishing's itch.io pageResults
| Criteria | Rank | Score* | Raw Score |
| Audio / Sound Design | #5 | 3.308 | 3.308 |
| Art Style / Visuals | #12 | 3.231 | 3.231 |
| Overall | #20 | 2.981 | 2.981 |
| Gameplay / Fun / Engagement | #27 | 2.769 | 2.769 |
| Halloween / Theme | #39 | 2.615 | 2.615 |
Ranked from 13 ratings. Score is adjusted from raw score by the median number of ratings per game in the jam.
How does your game interpret and use the Theme / Halloween?
Nothing can be caught during the day light hours, the world and fish/spirits are Halloween themed.
Game Engine?
Game Engine / Tools (Other)?
I've got a bevy of tools that I've built for myself to build games - art, music, 3d model pipelines
Graphics & Audio: What did you create or use?
Have you participated in a game jam before this one?
Roughly how much time did you spend developing? (in hours)
20 hours between the building & testing of the game.
Anything else you'd like to share about your game or development process?
I've been having a lot of fun exploring building games, thanks for hosting a game jam
Leave a comment
Log in with itch.io to leave a comment.





Comments
There is a lot here, and visually this is one of the more polished jam entries I’ve played. The environments look good, the supernatural fish have some fun designs, and the audio supports the quiet nighttime atmosphere well.
I also liked the idea of temporary fishing schools appearing in the water. Having a glowing area where rarer fish might show up gave me a reason to pay attention to the lake instead of casting anywhere.
Where the experience lost me was the core fishing loop.
Being able to move the targeting circle anywhere on the water and then cast directly to that point made the charge mechanic feel unnecessary to me. I was holding to build power, but the cast was already going where I had placed the target, so I didn’t feel like I was developing any skill around distance or placement.
The reeling itself was more intuitive. Holding to reel, watching tension rise, and releasing to give the line some slack made sense immediately.
What confused me was the additional connection meter. I understood the tension display and the distance/progress bar, but I never developed a clear understanding of what I was supposed to do differently because of the connection meter.
It mostly felt like another thing to monitor rather than another meaningful decision.
That was a recurring feeling for me throughout the game. There are fish to collect, a journal, ingredients to gather, bait to craft, different lakes, moon phases, temporary schools, and other systems layered on top of the experience.
Conceptually, that sounds substantial, but I never became invested enough in the basic fishing to want to explore all of that depth.
I think I would rather have seen fewer systems with more depth in the fishing itself.
For example, casting accuracy, fish behavior, bait choice, tension, and positioning could interact more strongly so that catching different fish requires noticeably different approaches. Then the journal, crafting, and moon-cycle systems would feel like tools that help me master that central activity rather than additional things to keep track of.
I also had some interface issues in the browser. Right-click camera control was awkward when the cursor left the game area, fullscreen did not work properly for me, and several HUD/text elements could still intercept or select with the mouse.
With so much information already on screen, those small usability issues made the interface feel busier than it needed to be.
The presentation is strong, and there are clearly a lot of working systems here. For me, the missing piece was a fishing loop compelling enough to make me want to dig into all of those surrounding systems.
Thanks for the feedback, I'll keep iterating and will incorporate this!
The game is super cozy and chill; it’s very soothing. The low-poly style was a great choice for this project. I would have liked a larger map—to avoid hitting the cliffs—but I love seeing such unique takes for this time of year, where you’ve completely reimagined fishing games in your own style. I would have appreciated a bit more context regarding who I am or why I’m doing this, but what I played was a calm, peaceful experience that really helped me enjoy the atmosphere.
Thanks for the feedback, I'll look at expanding it over time!
i went out for a fish and ended up checking the moon calendar over a ghost guppy. letting it go and finding its little echo in the cabin aquarium the next day was my favorite part. i brewed moonpetal bait and the odds panel showed the guppy going from 6 to 19 percent in open water that night which made the bait feel worth learning about.
on the dock i lost a catch by leaving the line slack and i saw someone had the opposite problem holding too long. at pumpkin jetty i got a cinder sardine once i settled into holding and letting go in short bursts. id put a little moving marker on the tension strip with a clearly shaded middle band and keep the hold or release hint right beside it. that would give me one place to look when the fish starts pulling. my guppy card said whispering cove even though i cast from lantern dock so id label that as its preferred spot and show where i actually caught it separately.
if you feel like taking a break from the lake give purr or treat the midnight reef a try. id love a rating and a note about what you noticed.
Thanks for the feedback! I'll look at adding those enhancements! I'll check your game out too!
Achei um jogo bem de boa, sabe quando chega cansado depois de fazer, esse seria um jogo que jogaria nesses casos dá pra perceber algumas inspirações, sendo um bom jogo!
Thank you, I'm glad you enjoyed it!
The lake and lanterns have such a lovely, cozy feel! I tried fishing at Lantern Dock, though some reeling instructions overlapped in my small browser window. A little more spacing would help. If you get a chance, we’d love your honest thoughts on A Borrowed Shadow too!
Thanks for the feedback, I'll adjust things!
Lantern Lake at night looked lovely, with the moonlit water, the stone circle and the lanterns setting a calm Halloween mood. Casting at night, waiting for the nibble and hooking a curious visitor felt cozy and clear once night arrived. My constructive note is that the reel tension was easy to lose, since my catch slipped after a few long holds, so a gentler first catch or a clearer tension hint would help new anglers.
Thanks for the feedback - I'll look at the reel tension.
Very cozy game, smooth and no need to rush, relaxing game. Music was very relaxing. Graphics were solid and keeped consistent style. Some graphic issues like bob on the ground, but that doesnt really matter if game is fun to play.
Overall fun and good looking relaxin game
Ps. I have no experience of making 3D game.. yet.
Thanks for the feedback!
Thanks for the feedback, I'll adjust the cast versus night trigger.
Have to be near the water at night to fish
that's fair, and the cast was the part I wanted to keep trying.
mine is in this jam too, Show yourself. if you get to it, tell me what the first minute reads as. that's the part I can't see anymore.
I'll take a look for sure - I just have to do my 5 assigned first :)