Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Pixel icons vs soft vector icons — how to pick, and why the filter setting is the whole answer

A topic by yangjuejue created 9 days ago Views: 58
Viewing posts 1 to 1

I make both kinds, so people ask which one they should use, and the honest answer is that it depends on the game — not on which is "better".

Pixel art (hard 16-bit edges, limited palette)

- Reads best at its native grid. Mine are all 64x64 deliberately, so they tile with the rest of a 16-bit scene.

- Suits top-down RPGs, roguelikes, anything with a chunky grid aesthetic.

- Needs Point / Nearest filtering in-engine.

Soft vector (rounded, warm, anti-aliased)

- Reads well at any size — the same asset works at 32px and at 256px with no re-authoring.

- Suits cosy / management / life sims, anything with a rounded visual language.

- Needs Linear / Bilinear filtering. Forcing Point on it makes it jagged and broken-looking.

The mistake I see most often: mixing the two without a rule. A few soft icons floating inside a pixel tileset looks like the asset pack ran out, not like a decision. Either commit to one language, or make the split intentional — soft UI chrome over a pixel world is a legitimate and popular setup, it just has to look deliberate.

And the practical bit that actually decides it: filter mode. On both engines, switching an asset's filter is a one-line change, and getting it wrong is the #1 reason an asset "looks wrong" in-game. If something you bought looks soft and blurry, it is almost never the art — it's Point/Bilinear.

I ship both styles rather than picking one and calling it the only correct answer, because half the people downloading would have been sold the wrong thing. If you tell me your genre and target resolution I'll tell you honestly which to use.

The pixel side:

https://yangjuejue.itch.io/pixel-icon-starter (12 icons, free)

https://yangjuejue.itch.io/pixel-icon-set-36 (36 icons, $9)

The soft side:

https://yangjuejue.itch.io/soft-icon-set-12 (12 soft-vector icons, $5)

Curious what the rest of this board is working in — if you're doing cosy/soft art I'd genuinely like to see it, I've been mostly heads-down in 16-bit.