It could still get rejected, honestly. Going arcade and dropping players straight into the action covers their "land new users in gameplay immediately" rule, but that's only one item on their list. Their originality line covers names and assets too, so a game called Duck Hunter 3D might still look close to an existing duck hunting game to a reviewer, even if it plays nothing like one.
The rest of their checks are pretty mechanical: text has to stay readable in small iframe sizes like 907 x 510, physics should behave the same at 144 Hz, and the game needs English. It's worth testing those before you resubmit. If you can, ask their support which check it actually failed, since that's the only way to know for sure.
Fingers crossed on the third try.