Sorry it took so much time to write, I had a busy week.
This is definitely just my personal thoughts, and now that the deadline is extended I hope I'd be able to finish another project; so hopefully it isn't much 'post-mortem' as 'thoughts in / on the process.' Please don't think I am unhappy with anything, again, these are just my thoughts.
I want to write this because the project I've submitted on November 2 was not the same map I keyed on October 23. "Some strange places on Charred Coast" was my forth (4.5 sort of) attempt to write and finish a hexcrawl for this jam, and I've started 'Some strange places..." on October 30 after I thought I already locked-in on a different hexcrawl idea (#3, "The Labyrinth") and did another small map for fun and to reset the mind a bit, and then sort of just went with it instead. Previous three hexcrawls were written rather far but each hit a snag, and I want to tell how they went, because I think some other people are struggling too.
My first attempt quickly just started to became an adventure instead of hexcrawl. As soon I thought about the town sitting on a river and imagined some Halloween-like festival going in, it dominated everything else and the rest of the hexes just became terrains with nothing much of their own going in not related to the festival. I folded this idea because the Hexcrawloween is supposed to be a hexcrawl, not a structured adventure which can only play out in a certain period of a year.
One of the struggles through the month was that once there was any settlement of more than 40 people anywhere on a map, it sort of became the main hub of everything, the most important place. Any town, or big village or, especially, if there was more than one and there was some connection between them, quickly became very complex thing in my mind. It was especially true for #1 (Festival) but it was true in all other places too. Settlement means society to me and any society is a rather complex thing, with its own problems, customs, important people, quirks, secrets. I also always struggle with NPCs and, unless the settlement is just ARPG town with blacksmith, sage and priest (i.e. not an actual settlement but an interface for upgrades), it is very difficult for me to write because I don't know how to convey this complexity and all those people, in a reasonable amount of space.
Attempt #2 (in which I used the random rolls from Hexcrawloween 1 for inspiration) became a small town in Cold War era somewhere in Oregon, where a secret research on a military base nearby (initially evacuated with the Operation 'Paperclip') was awakening some witchy things. This one was better in sense that it wasn't tied to a specific time of the year (unlike the previous festival which was), and it was sort of slow disaster in a making, and the factions were more clear. But it still really wanted to veer into an adventure instead of hexcrawl, and I found that research into Cold War era was both very exciting and kind of exhausting. I did the research because Cold War era was a real – and relatively recent – time, and I found myself instinctively trying to be much more historically accurate and less fantastical. And learning those details, I couldn't just leave them out and I felt I now need to include all those little details into the text (such stuff, for example, as a chart of chain of command for the military base with all the titles), so the text became very clogged and way too long again. I also sort of failed on the map for it, because I don't find modern-like maps too exciting. It being set in post-WW2 USA also made me doubt if it was a good idea, because I thought it might be completely non-compatible with the the rest of the jam.
I realized at this point that I don't know what is hexcrawl really because I actually never really wrote one and only hex-crawled once as a player. So I looked up some hexcrawls people recommend and was amazed by how much different they were from what I thought they are supposed to be.
A week was then lost because I tried to write concisely like in many of those hexcrawls and mimic their structure. I thought then that while hexflower map is very nice idea, because it is only seven of hexes, because it was so few of them each hex out of seven felt very important; I didn't think I could leave any of them 'empty', like in bigger hexcrawls, and I thought that something notable has to be going in each, because otherwise it sort of felt like a waste of a precious hex.
I also liked hexflower map idea for this Hexcrawloween because when I saw it it immediately reminded me AD&D gothic horror setting 'Ravenloft' where each of domains was kind of its own separate terrain strung together into Demiplane of Dread without too much coherency in, say, tech-levels (one domain might be antiquity, another one could have firearms). While these domains wheren't strictly round most of them are sort of lumpy too. So I thought 'what if I make sort of Ravenloft domain (only without Mists)?'
Attempt #3, Labyrinth went initially very well. It was a small barony with a big but not fully active villain sitting in a middle of an eldritch labyrinth, and a bunch of factions with different goals wanting to exploit a special resource (Labyrinth Roses) or having some other goals; the barony was remote and cursed enough that a bigger world didn't much care about it. I imagined it very well, it wasn't time-sensitive or too rigidly structured like Festival, and it gave me more freedom to imagine than Cold War-era Withtown. The usual problem of the settlements becoming too important was still there, but I thought the city of Trench and Clearwater village (two main settlements) were abstracted enough so I didn't feel I need to draw a town map like I did for the Festival. I was writing it, and on October 30 Friday drew a small map just for fun, to return later to writing the Labyrinth. The problem suddenly became the dungeons, because I at his moment realized that I've never wrote a proper dungeon before either, and everything I wrote about the barony now required two dungeons and one of them must be about 40 rooms. It was mid-day Friday, and no way I could made it before the deadline. I sort of wrote myself into the corner with this idea and was not prepared for everything that it needed. I put "Labyrinth" on hold and wrote 'Strange Places..." for the map I've made earlier in a day instead. "Strange Places..." was partially based on notes I made through the month, and could be a land in the same world as Festival and Labyrinth is, so it wasn't fully out of blue, but still it was kind of spontaneous. I didn't try to mimic the style of other hexcrawls, I just wrote how I saw it.
Dungeon of The Well was still difficult but because it didn't have to be a castle in the middle of Labyrinth, I had time to make it. I think it was a good thing that this year it wasn't a requirement of a specific amount of rooms, but any number rooms. I even thought about making unidungeon, as a joke.
What was a big help with 'Strange Places...' is that the map had an extra hex. I never described it, it isn't even fully on a map, but the round shape of the hexflower even in previous three attempts always tried to escape the hexflower and expand into more hexes. I do like hexflowers, but I did find it difficult to work with such small hexflower as a _shape_, strangely enough: It is so circular and sort of perfectly clumped up together, the way the natural terrain rarely is, and, I think, adding this extra ghost hex (even if it was eventually not a part of anything) helped me a lot to feel that the place I am describing is a part of some bigger world. I think if I'd need to write more hexflowers I will always add that 8th ghost hex just as a mental trick for myself.
One of the lessons I've learned was that making the text ready takes at least twice as much time as simply writing the text. Re-reading, last minute corrections, typos, struggle to fit the text into the page (layout program crashed half-way) and so on takes a lot more time than simply writing it. And even after I thought I found all typos, I keep finding new ones. My fonts are kind of haphazard. If the deadline wasn't extended I'd likely would have been late, especially because itch.io froze near midnight, right as I was last-minute uploading.
A few small thoughts at the end:
• I think creating "How everyone is getting one" thread was a very good idea.
• I really like 'Hexcrawloween' name; I think it is very clever and neat pun. I really like the requirements for both 1st and now 2nd Hexcrawloween, which I think an ideal "recipy" for mini-settings. In a way, I am still not sure if I've created a proper hexcrawl and not a mini-setting.
• I was also very inspired by the way everybody made maps, especially csaunders' ceramic map, it made me think of other ways to make a physical hexcrawl. Without access to a kiln I wanted to try to make polyclay hexes instead; I also got a bunch of wooden hex chips and drew some stuff with paint markers as a test, but I couldn't get it quite as detailed as I'd like. I also wanted to use collaged stickers with public domain art as illustrations and typewrite the whole thing to make a zine as purely analogue, but definitely run out of time. I was very glad to see people doing their own art.
• I've learnt that while overland map is ok to be photographed, my dungeon maps are likely look better if scanned because any photograph creates too much light gradient for it to look nice and flat (I currently don't have a scanner). Wish there was a permission to edit the edges of the scan or photo so to make a layout look a little better. Salaries & $tarships' "The Star Fall at Eisenstein" has very nice layout but it was very interested to see how everybody approached their.
• Table of random encounters was also very difficult to write (I only managed 1d12; hope to expand it on an update). The permission to split it into smaller parts was nice and I am kind of amazed when some people have more than one big encounter table.
• I really liked that the jam was here a week before it actually started, because it gave me some time to think on ideas.
Thank you for your time and thank you everybody for making this jam.
Apologies of everybody I didn't mention directly, but please know I am very glad you were here.