Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines
(+2)

Yes, no problem! I fired up the game again to refresh myself for further feedback. For me, the biggest factor that would contribute to a greater sense of realism is the use of more modulation to sculpt your phrases. Your vibrato, expression, and dynamic remain quite static across long stretches of melody. When I listen, for example, to the flute line of the main overworld theme, I don't get much of a sense of these expressive parameters being harnessed to sculpt the melody at the phrase level, to give it a semblance of the sort of natural arc one hears when a real player performs a melody; I feel this is especially important when mocking up orchestral music, where such a great deal of the expressive content is in how phrasing is handled. In these renderings, long notes at the end of phrases often seem to stay full-value in dynamic and vibrato until they end abruptly; a live player would almost always taper off the dynamic as they near the end of a phrase, usually while also widening the vibrato. If you watch professional composers making mockups, you'll notice that while the right hand is playing the melody, the left hand is resting on a fader bank, sculpting the phrase as they play. I think taking a little time to tend to those details would make the music punch in a higher weight class, so to speak.
One other small thing (and admittedly this is more of a taste thing): for me, some of these tones (the solo violin tone in particular) are in the uncanny valley of musical realism. The violin doesn't fully sound like a synth, but it doesn't really sound like a violin sample. It isn't to my taste, and in my own work I try to commit in one direction or the other. There are many free options, both in the more realistic camp and the more overtly synthetic camp.
I want to reiterate that you've done very nice work, and this is all just one man's opinion.

(1 edit)

Funnily enough, I actually played flute and saxophone on some of the tracks! (I assume you were hoping for more organic sounds haha.) I’m a jazz/classical flute and saxophone player/performer, so Mou and I really wanted to incorporate live instruments wherever we could, even with the short amount of time we had. You can hear me a little more clearly if you stick around a little longer in the repairman’s shop and during woodwind town’s track after percussion comes in! I’ve been thinking of uploading our tracks on YouTube or something.