I like the trivia touch! I only ever got brown sludge, though. Some feedback on near-misses (a hint, or a different message when a combination is close) would help me understand the logic.
yeah, it is a bit tricky to understand how much information I need to give to players, who do not know the answer, while I do.. I.e too much hints and it is trivial, too little and it is impossible.. But a hint - the trivia may or may not contain some pointers :)