Thank you for the detailed feedback!
You hit two things that have come up a few times now.
The retrieve control is there with right-click, Backspace, or B on controller, but the game does a poor job of telling you that when you actually need it. I definitely think a contextual “retrieve” prompt after a bad cast would help.
And I agree on the tension system. The release-for-slack mechanic was intended to matter much more than it currently does, but I didn’t get enough time for a proper balancing pass. Right now it’s too forgiving, so holding the reel down works far more often than it should.
I also really appreciate the comments about the atmosphere and little details. The fog, ripple effect, custom cursor, spirit designs, and overall quiet/lonely feeling were all things we spent a lot of time trying to get right, so it’s great to hear those landed.
Thanks for squeezing it in before the jam ended!