Congrats on this work, original mechanics are rare to find in horny itch games :P This seems like an early prototype, and I hope you continue to work on it. With a lot of polish, this game has potential to be a classic.
I did finish the game, but I struggled with several aspects of the gameplay and UI. I have professional history with game and UI design, so you might find my experience helpful as playtester feedback. A lot of the difficulties I found can be improved by UI. I will be critical of a lot of specifics here, please do not take these personally - I am only being this thorough because I am excited for the potential of your game. Take or leave them according to your judgement.
Stuff that works great
- core mechanic is an original idea and has some depth to it. huge points for you
- 'horniness delivery' is related to the player's mastery of the core mechanic; many itch games have unrelated puzzle mechanics and then give pictures as a reward, and they are very boring
- new understanding is delivered to the player in understandable stages. if you polish this aspect, you can probably remove some of the tutorial text
- overworld doors are gated by performance in the core mechanic
- magical abilities are varied and have interesting effects. you can deepen the game by having more of them or making sure that all of them are used meaningfully at least once through the course of the game
Gameplay issues I found
Overall I would say lean harder into the core mechanic. The more you can blend your existing mechanics into the 'photo battle' idea, the cleaner and more focused it will be. Trim out stuff that doesn't use it, or find a way to blend it in.
- For example, instead of having HP and MP upgrades in the overworld, maybe you can see a HP item tucked in a certain girl's top, and it is released when you destroy the top for the first time.
- a lot of design seems to be 'because it's like Pokemon' - if this is important, I would use Pokemon-only characters. If not important, reconsider some of the other Pokemon-y decisions and see if they really need to be there.
- tree collision shape was annoying - the overworld doesn't need to be tiles. you can get an artist to make it way prettier and use invisible walls instead
- everyone is right about the carnival minigames :P they are frustrating and don't share the core mechanic. I would just remove them and replace with more girls and tags to deepen the core instead of distracting from it. if you really want to keep them, be sure that the game can be completed without it, and tell the player so at the entrance
- similarly, the bomb puzzles are frustrating. if you really want to keep the bomb, remove the time limit, otherwise I would remove the bomb. here are some example alternatives:
- using the bomb to access Midna to get your first ATK point - instead of Daisy refusing you, she gives you a cheeky selfie as your first pic to get you started. this reinforces her role as the helpful tutorial girl
- using the bomb to get your first MP - using the 'upgrades hidden in the girls poses' option, or maybe MP come from "nipple points" in the same way that your ATK power comes from "pussy points"
- Coco easter egg - maybe Coco has a secret fetish that you can unlock with a rare pose from another character when talking to her
- if the same patch of flowers always encounters the same girl, you might as well just have the girl standing or walking in the overworld
- I struggled for a while to understand that you must attack with a photo _before_ using 'Push' - I thought that Push was the way that you "apply" the tags from the photo
- I still have no idea what the gems do. if they are relevant to gameplay the UI should say so
- I struggled to understand how to get all poses. I think it has to do with order, eg [ATK -> Arms -> Push] and [ATK -> Push -> Arms] gives you different poses, but this is not very discoverable
- AI content is ok as a placeholder for WIP, but see if you can collab with an artist for future updates. they can design you original characters, give you better coherence between pictures, have a beautiful overworld, it would be a huge win
UI issues I found
UI is where you can make this game really shine. These are a bunch of changes I would make as a professional UI designer, of course its your game not mine, but I hope these are helpful for you to continue polishing :)
- When a gate asks you for a photo to unlock, you must remember what it asked for, close the text, open your album, set a photo as 'active photo', and then click through the gate's text all over again. instead, just show the album when the gate asks, and pick the photo immediately. currently, you can 'fail' at opening a gate, which is silly. similarly, in the encounter screen you are almost always going to pick a different photo to start, so keeping the 'active photo' doesn't do anything for the player. instead, start with no selected photo and choose one by clicking on the photo slot. this allows you to remove the 'active photo' concept completely.
- As a general rule, users will fail to read text. The more you can communicate through the UI design, the better.
- gate interaction doesn't need to be a text convo at all. just show the photo tag requirements, and the photo picker. even better if you can do both on one screen, so the player doesn't have to remember while searching photos
- you can fit more text in each speech bubble, reducing number of clicks to get through the convo
- use right-mouse button to close all dialogs. this is a very effective one-handed UI pattern. use this absolutely everywhere for maximum consistency, and your game will feel smooth as hell
- you use the mouse-hover interaction a lot to display key information, such as player's current attack power. I would move important info to the main UI, and use hover to provide only additional help or context
- show attack power next to attack buttons, similar to how you already show heart requirements next to the special buttons. use hover to explain why (+2 pussy power, +1 from certain tags, etc). this also makes it easier to understand the effects of swapping out the selected photo
- make mouse targets bigger. clicking the small '...' to proceed the text should just be 'click anywhere on screen'.
- if an overworld item/character is clickable, give them a small effect on hover, like a glow outline. additionally, many overworld items could be activated by colliding with the player avatar instead of click, such as gates and signs.
- show all special attack (push/bind/etc) buttons at all times, but have them be faded/disabled when you don't have enough hearts. this communicates the heart rules without text
- move Magic toggle to it's own button, use 'click on photo' to open the album picker instead. hover on the magic button to explain active magical effects. remove 'Album' button from encounter screen
- definitely need a way to access a list of tags and their magical effects. it is difficult to find knowledge you need by opening every photo in the album, and I forget what was on the previous screen after a while
- in the photo picker, keep the left side for photos and the right side for tags. change tags on the right side as you hover the photos. this reduces the number of required clicks. if you remove the 'active photo' concept, clicking the photo shows you the large view, RMB closes it.
- needs impact VFX (like a 'POW!' or some particles) to show then the girl's attack procs. currently invisible and silent
- keep progress bar display for clothes HP, but also use them for Flee and Attack timers, so the player can see what is going to happen visually, without reading
- red and blue bars behind player's HP and MP should also work like a progress bar, not just numbers. unify how the girl's bars and the player's bars are displayed to make the presentation consistent
- move 'Run' button to group it together with the player's other actions
- use a camera icon or cursor next to target's photo instead explaining with text