Hello everyone!
I have a question and a feature suggestion regarding itch.io's developer profiles.
Currently, itch.io allows users to rate and review individual games, but what about the developers themselves?
Wouldn't it be useful to have a public Developer Reputation or Trust Score associated with each developer's profile?
I'm not talking about rating individual games. I'm referring to a reputation system that evaluates the developer as a whole, independently of their individual projects.
Why would this be useful?
A public developer reputation system could help users:
- Identify trustworthy and reliable developers.
- Make more informed decisions before purchasing games.
- Understand a developer's history and relationship with the community.
- Distinguish established, reliable developers from potentially suspicious accounts.
- Build more confidence when supporting new or independent developers.
What could the system include?
For example:
- Developer Reputation Score: An overall reputation score.
- Trust Score: An indication of how trustworthy an account is.
- Community Feedback: Feedback about the developer's communication and conduct.
- Account Reliability: A record of responsible account activity.
- Verified Developer Badge: An optional verification indicator.
These scores should not simply be calculated from the average ratings of a developer's games. They should consider the developer's overall conduct, account history, policy compliance, and community interactions.
Of course, such a system would need safeguards against review manipulation, harassment, and unfair ratings, especially for new developers.
My questions:
- Do you think itch.io would benefit from a public developer reputation and trust system?
- Would you find a developer's reputation score useful when deciding whether to purchase or support their games?
- Do you think this should be a separate system from the existing game rating and review system?
I believe this could improve transparency, accountability, and trust across the itch.io community.
I'd love to hear what other developers and players think about this idea!