Skip to main content

Indie game storeFree gamesFun gamesHorror games
Game developmentAssetsComics
SalesBundles
Jobs
TagsGame Engines

Would a Public Developer Reputation and Trust Score Be Useful on itch.io?

A topic by MisaelDevStudio created 11 days ago Views: 151 Replies: 3
Viewing posts 1 to 4

Hello everyone!

I have a question and a feature suggestion regarding itch.io's developer profiles.

Currently, itch.io allows users to rate and review individual games, but what about the developers themselves?

Wouldn't it be useful to have a public Developer Reputation or Trust Score associated with each developer's profile?

I'm not talking about rating individual games. I'm referring to a reputation system that evaluates the developer as a whole, independently of their individual projects.

Why would this be useful?

A public developer reputation system could help users:

  • Identify trustworthy and reliable developers.
  • Make more informed decisions before purchasing games.
  • Understand a developer's history and relationship with the community.
  • Distinguish established, reliable developers from potentially suspicious accounts.
  • Build more confidence when supporting new or independent developers.

What could the system include?

For example:

  • Developer Reputation Score: An overall reputation score.
  • Trust Score: An indication of how trustworthy an account is.
  • Community Feedback: Feedback about the developer's communication and conduct.
  • Account Reliability: A record of responsible account activity.
  • Verified Developer Badge: An optional verification indicator.

These scores should not simply be calculated from the average ratings of a developer's games. They should consider the developer's overall conduct, account history, policy compliance, and community interactions.

Of course, such a system would need safeguards against review manipulation, harassment, and unfair ratings, especially for new developers.

My questions:

  1. Do you think itch.io would benefit from a public developer reputation and trust system?
  2. Would you find a developer's reputation score useful when deciding whether to purchase or support their games?
  3. Do you think this should be a separate system from the existing game rating and review system?

I believe this could improve transparency, accountability, and trust across the itch.io community.

I'd love to hear what other developers and players think about this idea!

(+1)

I like the goal, but I think a public score would mostly hurt the developers it's meant to help. New devs would start at zero or "unknown" and look suspicious next to established accounts, which is the opposite of what a small indie needs.

Anything that lets people rate a person rather than a product also becomes a target for brigading the moment someone gets into a public argument.

To your third question, if it existed it should definitely be separate from game ratings, and I'd keep it to checkable facts like account age, number of releases, and whether updates and devlogs keep coming, rather than a number other users vote on. Some of that you can already piece together from a dev's profile and their game pages.

Honestly the thing that makes me trust a dev most is seeing them actually answer comments on their own game page.

(+1)

No. Profiling and ranking individual people is vile. We need less of that in the world.

Additionally,

  1. Itch.io would not benefit from this.
  2. This is one of the only places left on the internet where I put in any trust in ratings, primarily because it’s pretty much pointless for bots or hate campaigners to target them. If you notice, few projects have ratings, they are used for little for sitewide purposes, and they don’t really matter in aggregate. That’s good as-is.
  3. Do I think this should be a separate system from the existing game rating and review system? Yes, it shouldn’t exist.
  4. What’s the point? Personal evaluation works fine. Do you want to play the game? Then play the game. Do the assets look genuine and useful? Download them. Want to work with the developer? Ask if they want to work with you, too. Have doubts that a game or developer is worth engaging with? Move on, ask around privately, or take a reasonable risk of acting in good faith. These are basic skills for healthy social systems.

No.

While Itch has a follow mechanic, it does not have the content creator fixation. While games can be seen as content, they differ fundamentally from videos on youtube, as a contrast. Or images on instagram. Or other social media with user generated content.

It is the indie plus hobby version of gated publisher content. The Steam for people that can not publish on Steam for lack of professionalism.

Any type of trust score would be abused to hell and back by malware uploaders. For legit users (and every account is able to publish here) it would be no good, since the abundance of users would not meet any trust metric. And at the point where they would meet such criteria, it would not be needed anymore. You do not need a trust score for an account with 1k followers to have that account appear more or less trustworth than an account with 20k followers. This is not eBay.

Oh, and Itch does have a verified account system, it is just not used in general. If you look at /games/top-sellers you will see some accounts with a checkmark for verified account.