Renpy games store their save data in your user's program config area. This is what allows them to carry over between versions.
Windows: %APPDATA%\RenPy\<game>
Linux: ~/.renpy/<game>.
macOS: ~/Library/RenPy/<game>
Find yours and delete or rename it. Also remove the game>saves folder in your installation directory, where backup copies are kept. Or just delete and reinstall.