Hello! As thanks for playing my game, I also gave yours a go. Here are my somewhat-messy thoughts after about half an hour of play:
- I would set Master volume to 50% by default. It felt a bit loud at 100% to me.
- The main menu is relatively cute and has some character. The subtle movement is nice.
- When looking at starting characters, it is unclear to me what an "Echo" is (though after I started playing, it became clear that they are essentially fieldable party members).
- I feel like tooltips take too long to appear (which is easily changeable with a Project Setting in Godot, iirc). However, the tooltips themselves are fairly informative, which is good.
- Card text can be difficult to read at a glance.
- The starting decks have a lot of unique cards (7) and it makes picking a hero a little overwhelming to start. For a comparison, most Slay the Spire starting decks have just 3-4 unique cards, which helps ease you into the game.
- I picked Herodotus to start as the other character seemed more confusing haha. I'm aware the assets are AI, but his voice immediately struck me as unfitting for the boyish portrait.
- I would like to be able to click to advance/fast-forward through text (even if it's voiced).
- Is there a reason for the 5-second countdown to being combat? It doesn't seem necessary given the game is otherwise turn-based.
- The "selection wheel" for each character seems a bit too big, taking up the whole screen. I feel it would make more sense if it instead appeared around the character when clicked?
- It took me a bit to figure out where my "mana" was; might be good to make it more visible!
- Again, it might be AI, but the battle theme(s) feel exceedingly repetitive due to being very short loops. I think pure ambience would work better than what's currently there.
- For some reason, I kept trying to play cards by clicking on them, even knowing that I had to drag... :') But since you need to click a target after dragging anyways, maybe click-to-play would just feel better?
- The game does feel a bit slow to me, and standard encounters strike me as a little too lengthy for a roguelike. It took me 25 minutes to get through just two battles. I would look into rebalancing the game so that encounters don't last as long (could even be worth trying out fewer enemies with less HP, but maybe more damage being dealt by them?)
- The between-battle rewards feel a little overwhelming: pick a card, pick an echo, and then pick 2 keepsakes. Is there a way to spread these out more, perhaps?
- Elites should probably be more clearly marked. The little boss icon in the corner is easy to miss!
- The Death Mark icons seemed to be bugged for me. They would move around the field and appear quite far from the actually Marked enemies.
- On the whole, the game does have quite DnD-y vibes, which I do appreciate! I think the "roll for perception" and "roll for initiative" flavor text is quite cute, too, though it could be fun to have those be actual DnD-style mechanics.