Yep! I do like the progression feel of the game with upgrades and stuff, but the gameplay isn't as fun.
Reason 1: Piece inequality, reversed?
Pawns are by far the best piece. Everyone else feels exactly the same to use, except that they have slightly better stats. And the Knight, sucks. The King doesn't feel special, just a stronger pawn. The stronger part is an exaggeration: it barely changes. My recommendation would be to nerf pawns. Cap their max charge to half of the other pieces. King could have much more knockback resistance but no offence. Queen could be all out offensive. Rooks more defensive. Bishops being stronger when aiming diagonally. Etc.
Reason 2: Strategy
Ragdolls rock. Can't deny that. But it doesn't feel like I am playing something strategic. I am just playing bowling with chess pieces. And hitting my opponent doesn't even guarantee a win! I would make it so if the king dies, game over. So strategy is actually needed! And decrease the overall power of pieces. No piece should be able to be flung across the board(except knights) and hit 3-4 pieces. The only strategy is getting more upgrades. Sure its there but its between 3 so not really strategic.
Reason 3: Permadeath and draws
Permadeath+ragdoll physics is a bad idea. Ragdoll physics (especially in this game) like do get wanky. Draw is meant to be a "fix" i guess? Comes more as an annoyance. I can enjoy a semi random game. But winning them back to back? Not fun. Especially after loosing without knowing why(mainly ragdolls). Maybe make the levels much harder, but add saves. And please remove the upgrade cards since they all kind of suck and I don't feel them helping me much
Sorry for the negativity! I just want this game to be great and fun. I can't imagine myself programming the ai, the physics and online mode(especially online mode) and getting a comment like this